Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Paul - Elmira, NY — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 15:54:51 GMT

What is a "Digital Correspondent"? What is your job?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Fri, 25 Jul 2008 16:02:18 GMT

Why is this even a question or an issue. DO WHITE PEOPLE REPORT NEWS ON OTHER WHITE PEOPLE FAIRLY? These type of questions prove to the public how people of color are treated with suspicion and discriminated against by white supremacist even if they are just trying to do their jobs.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Eddie, Yorktown, VA — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 16:13:26 GMT

Not one person answered the question. They must be politicians in the making.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Phillip E. Banks — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:10:43 GMT

This is an absolutely ridiculous question! Mr. Mabry hit the nail on the head with his answer. It also reveals, to me anyway, that there is a question of whether or not any reporter can put aside personal feelings and objectively report on a subject that they either support or reject. Can an old, conservative, white reporter do an objective story on McCain? When the question is posed like this, can you see how stupid it is to even ask it? Are Black reporters to be held to another standard than others? The better question should be "Can bi-racial reporters cover Obama fairly"? No...that sounds stupid too.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Fuzzy Q. Jones — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:19:25 GMT

Can white journalists cover Obama fairly should be the question. Why is that when racial matters arise it is assumed that blacks will respond with emotionalism and subjectivity, while whites will respond with reason and objectivity? Documented history and current affairs demonstrate that whites are not always reasonable and objective in their thoughts, words and deeds regarding the lives of black people. Blacks are blamed for being lazy but feared if ambitious, blamed for being failures but resented for our success, blamed for lacking initiative but limited by the glass-ceiling imposed, and blamed for lacking culture but critized for owning institutions such as the church, colleges that foster and preserve our heritage.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jane Doe, Seattle, Wash — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:29:17 GMT

I think this article is so stupid and pointless. Does anyone ask a white person if they can cover a white candidate objectively? This articles just serves to perpetuate the racial divide. As a woman I would feel no specific sense of additional pride if a women were candidate for president. Shouldn't we be electing the best candidate for the job regardless of political affliation, race, gender etc. Until we do that we aren't going to see any progress

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Holly W, Pittsburgh, PA — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:33:07 GMT

I believe this notion of 'since America (finally!) has a black candidate for president that suddenly black journalists are at risk for subjectivity' is ridiculous. No one has ever questioned the majority of journalists, who are white, whenever there is a white candidate for president, senate, mayor etc. If you want to get formal, Obama is half white, so maybe only hispanic, asian, native american and non-white/non-black journalists should be covering the election. I have grown very tired of the 'since Obama is black' scenario. I believe it degrades everyone who is questioned and those who question them. I would like to think that if any journalist had a hard time remaining objective about a particular subject, that they would recuse themselves and allow someone else to do the coverage.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

jumphigher — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:34:01 GMT

I would've hoped by now that as Americans this type of "sterotyping" would cease. We're electing a President - not a "white" person or an "African American." It's this type of journalism that will continue racist attitudes in America. Let's cover the issues and not the color of someone's skin.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Prinny — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:48:22 GMT

Sorry Jumphigher you are dead wrong. To every black American supporting Senator Obama, the country is electing a black president. To many many Americans of other races the country is electing a black president. To journalists, black and white, the country is electing a black president. Let's not play games. This is not about substance, it is about a black man being elected president.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Leo Trump, Federal Way, WA — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:55:37 GMT

it's funny how people answer a seemingly easy question?... they create another question to avoid the issue... there are plenty of them some are running for election & others for reelection... hhmmm politicians in the making

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Samantha B — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 17:58:07 GMT

I presume that majority of the WHITE Presidents were interviewed by either a white liberals and conservatives and maybe a few blacks. But, why does the question have to be brought about now that we have a BLACK candidate running for office. There was really no questions as to why white reporter seemingly bash their own or races of candidates, senators, or other government officials. I know that as a black female I would try to report more of a subjective view, and maybe throw in some boosts for Obama but keep them strictly factual. Instead of some TMZ scud point of view… We need to stop worrying about the color of skin and see who is a better candidate for all American people.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

ljp, Medford Lakes, NJ — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:08:17 GMT

It appears that not one reporter answered her question. They danced around the issue rather than answered it.That leads to another conclusion. "Where there is smoke, there is fire!"

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

JangoFett, Columbia, SC — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:14:41 GMT

Eddie from Yorktown makes an EXCELLENT point. These are journalists? Imagine having them working for you, giving them an assignment, and having them return with something other than what was assigned. :p

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

David, Sacramento, CA — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:17:39 GMT

I totally agree this is such a stupid topic to talk about. The scrutiny of Obama is so crazy these days. People are talking about is the media biased towards Obama. Yes he has gotten more coverage but most of it is negative in comparison to McCain. Even when it should be something positive, negative questions are always thrown out there with it.

SO now, the black media is being scrutinized to another standard just like Obama is. Do we question if Sean Hannity covers Obama fairly or does he have bias towards McCain? NO!! Do we ask this same question of white journalists about covering any other white candidate? NO, not that I can think of since I have been on this earth. It's just nuts how far the media is going to try anything in their power to not have Obama in office.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Ben Goldman, Atlanta GA USA — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:18:31 GMT

So I guess the appropriate question is "can journalists who self-identify as 'black' cover 'mixed heritage' Obama fairly?" As much as society keeps labeling the man black, he's not. He's of mixed race, and identifies as such.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

FVF — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:25:34 GMT

Why can't we all just be Americans...why do we have to have a prefix to our status as Americans.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

anotherperspective — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:28:39 GMT

I’m just curious, are any of you who commented black? I’m black and I don’t think it’s a stupid question. In fact I believe it’s a very thought provoking question. Have any of you heard of Tavis Smiley? Some time ago he expressed his opinion regarding Obama’s decision to not attend the annual “State of the Black Union” symposium. All of a sudden the once beloved Smiley was being maligned, criticized, being called a hater, jealous etc, all for simply saying : “"I think it is a miscalculation on his part not to appear and a missed opportunity." it seems that if you question anything about Obama, and you’re black, you’re branded a traitor, a hater, jealous etc. So I think it’s a legitimate question on several levels: does the fact that you’re proud of the historical moment, impede, influence your reporting? If you have questions that may be a little uncomfortable for Obama, do you not address them because you don’t want to be viewed as a hater, a spoiler of his bid for the White House. Due to the historical nature of his candidacy, it’s not just business as usual. And yes, I often wonder if conservative Republican reporters, as well as liberal Democrats are unbiased in their reporting. I also agree with the poster who commented that not one person actually answered the question.

Black Commenter, Criticizing Obama, Causes Firestorm (http://blog.washingtonpost.com/the-trail/2008/02/16/black_commenter_criticizing_ob.html)

Tavis Smiley, the bestselling author of the "Covenant With Black America," is in a world turned upside down. He said he's being "hammered," "barbecued," and is "catching hell" from black Americans for suggesting that Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) made a major mistake by declining to speak at the State of the Black Union event that Smiley plans to host next week in New Orleans.

Radio Host Says Tavis Smiley May Have Left Show Over Obama Flak
http://elections.foxnews.com/2008/04/12/radio-host-says-tavis-smiley-may-have-left-show-over-obama-flak/
Joyner said he thinks Smiley is tired of getting flak for criticizing Obama.“We’re so emotional about this Barack Obama candidacy,” Joyner said on his Dallas-based show. “If you don’t say anything for Barack Obama, you’re considered to be a hater.”
Smiley criticized Obama for not attending an annual “State of the Black Union” symposium Smiley held in February. Sen. Hillary Clinton was the only presidential candidate who accepted Smiley’s invitation.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Opus. Portland, Me — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:29:03 GMT

As a white person who spent several years in my youth as the only white person on an all black baseball team i strongly believe a good black or good white reporter could do a good job reporting on Obama. The ublic perceptions would be all over the place though.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Rosaly Miller Cleveland, Ohio — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:37:45 GMT

It is disgusting that this subject would even come up. White reporters have been reporting on white candidates for years. No one has ever questioned thair sense of fairness or objectivity. Why is Sen. Obama subjected to such scrutiny? Its' a shame that, after all these years, African-Americans are still looked at with suspicion.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

EZquick — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:47:03 GMT

This article was written by a black female reporter who interviewed other black reporters. Yet, most of the comments from readers are white-bashing tirades, as if this entire question was another way for whitey to get at the bruthas and sistahs, despite conclusive evidence to the contrary: A black woman wrote the flippin article!!!

As a white man, I refuse to feel guilty over my gender or my race. We have accomplished much to much, even with our shortcomings. Deal with it.

As for about 92% of blacks voting for Obama nationwide in the primaries, well, draw your own conclusions.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Eddie — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 18:52:18 GMT

Why does everyone have to play this racism card. I am a minority (Hispanic) and I'll tell you up front. If I were a reporter and if Obama was Martinez I would be proud and I think I would have trouble being objective. We are breaking into a new frontier. This is the first time that we have a legitimate person of minority background running for President. How can you not be proud and somewhat prejudical towards him???? And by the way this is a Black Woman asking Black Reporters the question. Are you calling her an OREO????

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Fred — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:16:17 GMT

It is an honest question that takes into account human nature. All of the idealism aside, think about it honestly. Until everyone is the same color, it will always be an issue. I agree that everyone dodged the question with rhetoric, just as all the comments are filled with idealistic bitterness or just plain bigotry.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Barry,St Louis — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:26:21 GMT

I think they have forgotten that Obama is both black and white.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Dan Hortsch, Portland, Oregon — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:30:58 GMT

The question had never occurred to me (a retired, white newspaper journalist). "Can" black journalists cover Obama in an unbiased way? Of course! As with other journalists of every ethnic, religious and political stripe, the vast majority of professional journalists -- if not every single one -- take pride in working to the required standards of the job.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Joey, Baltimore, Maryland — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:34:08 GMT

White people who support McCain don't take a special PRIDE in McCain just because he is white.

The problem of setting up the "Obama Narrative" as a "historic moment in American history for African Americans" is this: what if McCain wins?

If McCain wins, no matter how good his ideas, no matter how deep his experience, no matter how empty Obama's promises are, too many people are going to attribute it to "racism". There will be all sorts of conspiracy theories, etc.

Honestly, since I don't particularly like McCain or Obama, I hope Obama wins. Maybe then people can stop making dubious complaints about racism and asking for special privileges (e.g. affirmative action, et al).

When it has been proven that in America, the land of opportunity, a black person can become president just like a white person, then minority special interest groups should stop making the case for taking billions of dollars in welfare programs.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Adam, Chicago, IL — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:39:08 GMT

Yes, they can. However, compairing a white journalist being able to cover McCain fairly is not an equal question. Obama enjoys 95% + support from the Black community...where McCain has less than 50% of white voters.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Charley James, Minneapolis MN — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:46:17 GMT

What an absurd question! If white reporters can cover white politicians fairly (as good ones have been doing in the US for some 240 years), why can't black journalists cover a black presidential candidate fairly? In any event, from what I've read and seen this campaign season, if anything black reporters and columnists seem to be tougher on Barack Obama than they have on the white candidates.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Debbie, Memphis, TN — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 19:57:17 GMT

Unfortunately, race is playing a rather large part in this election. Let's be honest...if white people were voting for McCain in the same percentages that black people are voting for Obama, what would the headlines be? We have come a long way, but the color of one's skin still matters as much or more than the content of their character. Both races are guilty. Until the racial bias ceases entirely, this subject will continue to divide us.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jonathan — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:03:45 GMT

Please note that this question was posed by a black journalist. The article would be receiving much more criticism if it were written by a white journalist. Sorry folks, racial bias still exists.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:28:53 GMT

I was struck by something Fuzzy Q. Jones said above. I will never understand how black churches can be viewed to foster or preserve the heritage of black Americans. He must be referring in large part to Christian churches and thus he is referring to the religion of the white slave owners. Therefore the heritage being preserved is perverse and not a true or logical heritage of the decedents of the slaves. You can't claim that black churches have adopted a different Christianity - they countenance the same 2 bibles as white Christians...you can only admit that Christianity is something that is sold to people by being selectively perverted to support virtually any human activity, any cause, fear or frailty. Thus has it been for 2,000 years and thus will Christianity always be.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Kathy, Chocowinity, NC — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:29:52 GMT

When will this country become color blind? It should only matter if the person can do the job.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Phyllis Kunz Louisville Ky. — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:31:55 GMT

I think there are some black and white anchors
NOT covering the Obama story fairly, and now
I am disillusioned. I thought we were past it,
but obviously not. I always took people as they
come, but I was naive, and hopefully, as a result,
I am more discerning about people.

I agree with Sen. McCain that Obama is acting as if he is
already President of the United States. This
"as-if" technique is juvanile and worries me.
Sen. McCain has my vote because he will continue
the foreign policy of Pres. Bush who is the
greatest president in modern history and worthy
of another term. Gee, I may write in his name.

Phyllis Kunz

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jack Denver, CO — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:37:16 GMT

It disgusts me that this is a legitimate item for discussion on a major media sight. I have never said "well that reporter covering Bush is biased because he is white and so is Bush." What a disgusting article.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Ray, Buffalo, NY — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:40:57 GMT

"S" The question wasen't asked by a white person. DUH

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Gino, Salem, Or — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 20:50:21 GMT

This a very valid question. After all, has not black society,in its friction dominated interaction with white
society,not set the stage for distrust and bias? Look at the street scene where bloodshed dominates discourse.
Look at the obvious bias of black witnesses in judging
their own in law cases. More exposure of these (biases)
will, hopefully, bring some light into the gray area.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

h vanpelt — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 21:10:34 GMT

Are any reporters really telling the whole truth? Does anyone? Do reporters with a personal liberal bias tend to see and report events to favor a liberal view while reporters who have a personal conservative bias see and report the same events to favor their personal bias. Do news organizations get reports from many points of view and work to minimize the bias or just rely on one reporter and flavor the story to ensure the report has commercial appeal?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

patton434 — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 21:12:01 GMT

Doesn't anyone find it odd that black journalists overwhelmingly write articles in shameless blatent support of Obama??!! How many are critical of him and ask the real tough questions? You won't see every white reporter supporting McCain... some do, some don't. The point isn't to say that black journalists are racist - that is not the case. The point is that they are simply letting their emotions manifest themselves in their writing. But regardless, it is definitely NOT objective reporting. The media has had a definite bias towards Obama since day 1. Not only does he get more press, but the press that he gets is always much more positively spun. This is a fact. I am not that easily brainwashed by these huge media corporations - I think on my own and will not let them shove Obama down my throat! If you are fine with a rich executive at some big media conglamorate brainwashing you into voting for a candidate so he can have an "in" into the White House... then you are the one who will have to live with your own lack of decency!!!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Kenneth Davis, Chicago, IL — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 21:25:34 GMT

The comments that say the question is pointless do not understand a few things. First of all, the fact that the question is being asked is an effect of the there being a viable candidate who is also a black man in America. That is one important point to the question. Secondly, the question *should* be asked because it point out specifically to white reporters that they probably cover whites and blacks differently. I'm sure most white reporters don't believe that they do, but black people see different coverage so often it is latent and blatant. . . Lastly, let's not forget that the case has been made that Obama has actually benefitted from the coverage he has been getting.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Dave, Tn — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 21:26:10 GMT

I distrust black and white liberal "journalist" equally I don't care who they are reporting on.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Kathy, Charlotte NC — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 21:55:23 GMT

Who are you again? You're ridiculous and so is your question.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Stephanie-Umbro, Maine — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 22:17:51 GMT

I must say, I'm on both sides of the fence on this question. As I write my response, I'm having difficulty just referring to people by their skin color.

As a white woman, part of me wants to know why would a black covering a black candidate be any different than a white covering a white candidate?

Then I remember that I am part of a minority: women. My gender, in years past, has been considered an inferior gender, in not so many words. So did anyone ask this question when Sen. Clinton was running? Can a woman objectively cover a woman presidential candidate? I know women of different colors who supported - and didn't - support her candidacy (I didn't either).

I have no doubt that blacks are excited and energized by seeing a fellow black in such an exalted position. I know that, while I do not support Sen. Clinton's positions, I was excited & energized by her historic run. Therefore, I don't see that this particular question is entirely relevant. I think the larger area of bias is with parties, not colors. I am must more likely to consider a candidate based on party affiliation rather than color. Should I choose to vote for Obama, he would also not be the first black I have voted for in my voting past.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

olu, washington, dc — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 22:43:14 GMT

Though it would appear that Blacks are voting for Obama because of his "race", one has to take into account the percentages of Blacks that identify themselves as democrat. That being the case, it is entirely reasonable that Obama would have overwhelming support among the Black community. With regards to McCane receiving 50% of the white vote, it is primarily due to whites being members of a variety of political parties. However, white political party membership is generally divided between repubicans and democrats. Once you get beyond the superficialities of the voting demographics, you will see that is just a matter of political affiliation.

For those who think there has been "whitey bashing", nothing could be further from the truth. Answering the question with "does anyone question the objectivity of a white journalist covering white candidates?" is not bashing white people, it is highlighting the ridiculousness of the topic question.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Morris Evans, Clackamas, Oregon — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 22:46:01 GMT

As I read through the many comments I struggle with the idea that we have come along way. Racism will always exists because there are people that believe in always wanting the upper hand. A man who happens to be BLack is running for President. I am proud of that fact, God made each of us equal. One day we all will have to give account of our own actions here on earth. Believe it or not. The reporters will do a good job for they know that they also are being watched.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

concerned, IL — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 23:25:17 GMT

the falsehood of the breakdown between race is a lie!
the real battle is between the rich & poor! the news is only 50% accurate 100% of the time at best.soon as
y'all figure where the real problem is & stop being devided and controlled by the rich,then we can weed
out the problem!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jackie Rawlings Riverside California — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 23:44:48 GMT

Well if Journalist just did their job regardless of color there should be no problem. Ok we know we still have problems but if Journalist would just look at the person as gray it shouldn't be a problem.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

John, Wisconsin — Fri, 25 Jul 2008 23:48:52 GMT

Lets first understand that all of us are bias in some way or another. I could understand that a Black repor ter would be proud and, maybe unknowinly be biased in his reporting. We all crazy if we don't accept the fact that we all, with few exceptions, report with rose colored glasses. The media is full of unabashed liberals and conservatives who proudly admit to it. Our real problem is when we have "reporters" who are so biased and try to pass themselves off as unbiased. Take for instance Keith Olberman on MSNBC. As inteligent a person that he is, he can not present a balanced story on the news, but he cann't admidt to his bias. On the other hand is Joe Scarbourgh, a conservative reporter with an attempt to present both sides of a discussion. This election has lost a great deal with the passing of Tim Russert and I can only hope that we, as consumers of broadcast journalizam, will demand more from those who stand on some soap box and try to "give us the facts".

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

The Real Deal — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 00:06:51 GMT

The juxtaposing of the question by Mabry is not logical. A white journalist covering a white candidate would not be covering the first white candidate in history, or a candidate with 90+% support from the white community.

The fact is that most black people see this as "our shot" and any black who is not an Obama cheerleader is demonized as an "Uncle Tom" (a silly term to use as a pejorative, btw, since Uncle Tom was the clear hero of the book) or "sell-out" or whatever.

I think the answer to the question is yes for most black journalists, but that doesn't mean it isn't a fair question.

Think of it this way: suppose a white guy was running for the city coucil seat for Harlem, and polls showed he had about 50/50 support among blacks but 90+% support from whites. Wouldn't it make you a little suspicious of the motives of a white reporter who lived in Harlem and wrote about the candidate?

Like I said, I have faith that most reporters try to be objective, at least to the extent that any human being can divide their personal experiences from their job, but this is a fair question. Lots of white people are asking themselves this already, so it is better that it comes from a black reporter. To ignore the issue would only make it more valid.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Eutonnah Balatinecz-american living in Canada — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 00:13:09 GMT

All of the comments I have read seem to be self-serving. I just wish there was no need in anyones heart to have to comment about someone that will be n the limelight long enough for EVERY ONE to make an unbiased judgement about Mr. Obama .

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

AlsoBiased, Greenwich,CT — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 01:06:49 GMT

As a white person I also think it is a stupid question, but for a different reason. First of all there is no such thing as unbiased news or news network anywhere. So every reporter (white or black or anything else) has a network bias in addition to a personal bias. In fact I think a network bias is a lot more damaging than a personal bias, since it brainwashes large segments of our population. So what if black reporters are biased. There are many other ethnic, religious, economic, political, business, geographical groups that are as biased. Why isn't anyone complaining about those biases.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Ed Smith colorado springs colorado — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 01:38:10 GMT

( jumphigher ) Got it right, this is for all of us and we need to be putting away our personal feelings.
black and white, we need to start working together for a common good and quit blaming.
Can a black reporter be impartial and stick to facts when they have so much invested in the outcome ? what do you think ?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Evander Duck — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 02:44:37 GMT

Question asked, is not deserving of a response.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

C., GA. — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 02:52:27 GMT

This was a ridiculous question and the color of the reporters skin makes no difference. In the same way that some women have acted against women's rights and interests (anti-choice, Brooke Hogan's recent comments on women being unsuitable for presidency)so can a black reporter to her own detriment, so to speak. One doesn't have to create the system to perpetrate it. Mabry got it right.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Dave — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 03:06:16 GMT

I think it is pretty telling that many of the responses run along the lines of "How dare you ask that question?"

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Stuckey, NC — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 03:34:14 GMT

Here is something I don't get. Question, if I were an american journalist covering the Olympics and someone said I would be bias in my coverage of the Olympics because I was proud of my country, I would say they were crazy. Why would I slant my coverage just because I was proud of the USA. It is ridiclous to me that anyone would think that as a journalist I would not be capable of seperating my pride from my duty as a journalist. Think about it, this is the same thing everyone is discussing here.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Lee, Alliance, oh — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 04:03:32 GMT

Im tired of the media acting like Obama is the next Massiah. I dont think anyone is reporting "honestly" about him. Its all hype, Obama the "rock star". Obama gets dap from michelle. I cant wait for him to lose already

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Aaron G., NM — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 04:06:01 GMT

With surprise that I can comment this late in the game:

I've fully enjoyed the entire comment section. It shows the beautiful spectrum of people not only concerned with their own lives, but also concerned about the direction of their beloved (if not most corrupt) country.

Folks, this question is both valid and invalid... However, I think that the ultimate perception of this article is whether or not it is an appropriate question to be had at this time in American History...

As most would agree, Blacks (African-Americans...I practically despise this division, by the way) have been free for a little over forty years--maybe fifty... Let's not forget that Martin Luther King died in 1968 and that blacks were still struggling for equality... and blacks are still struggling for equality.

The question here is whether or not this "equality" is an illusion or not... What truly is equality, and how does it relate to the world, country, and communities that we reside in?

In the course of the world, America will eventually come to a point of equality-through-experience. It is the only way that "equality" can be had. As many of you realize, to inform yourself NOT to do something, is almost more powerful than informing yourself to accomplish something...think "smoking" "fornicating" "evil".

Getting back (digressing from my ideological monologue), as quite a few have said, it is unfair to our society to continue identifying with separatist labelling in regards to our society. I have been over seas and Americans are seen as nothing more--nor less--than Americans. Period...

"Brothas" are addressed as "Brothas" and "Whiteys" are treated as such, but, in the end, we are seen as "Americans." Why do we not see things this way? Television, media, blah blah...are responsible. We know this. However, we are limited to these forces of society. We can read and learn through experience, but ultimately, the desire to understand has to originate in the individual...

This is the true source of change and progression: within.

So, folks, truly... Keep learning and progressing your thoughts... The universe rejoices...

Eventually, we will need to come together as the beautiful species that we are to take on the aliens who want to devour our brains... :-)

Until later...

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Neil R, Chester PA — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 04:13:58 GMT

Wow.
It seems like a few people here are pulling a Fox news and are interpreting answers with personal conjecture.
To educate those few people I'll admit my personal experiences of the presidential race. I can say truthfully I didn't think he was going to get far because America is very racist. Once he proved he wasn't another Jesse Jackson and started to show the media he can verbally handle himself then he got my attention. I wanted to vote for Dennis Kucinich but he didn't make the cut.
I support Obama not because he's black (I'm black as well) but because I'm a Democrat.
Most intelligent people (i'd like to believe) don't subscribe to tribalism.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Reese, Shreveport, La. — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 06:31:25 GMT

This is a fair question but not for the reason you think. The problem is that many African Americans (and some white) will vote for Barack Obama solely because he is black, and not for his qualifications or stance on the issues. The same would have been the case if Hillary would have been the nominee and have been the first woman potential President. In the past the candidates were always white men, so race was not an issue in the election or the news coverage there of. Any race or gender person covering the candidates had no way to be biased except on the issues. Now before all the hate mails that are sure to follow this, I will say that if I were in the position to possibly have the first person of my gender or my race to potentially be president I would have to "check" myself to understand exactly what is most important. Is it the historical moment, or the future of my country. Remember people this is not a vote to determine the winner of "Star Search", understand that this person (whomever it is) will hold the keys to our (YOUR) future for at least 4 years. Think about it.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

newsnut,houston,texas — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 07:49:44 GMT

Realisticy the way that seems logical, is that one can not fit a square peg into a round hole. A over zealous people can not see outside their own overwhelmnes. They become guick to cling to their own hangups of unequality and been downtrodden all my life, phycological block. Like the fella who decries that he would never be comsume by the fever of gold; Yet when he comes close enought to its majic attraction pull, he goes hog wild!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jas Land, Sierra Vista , AZ — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 08:52:14 GMT

This should not be questioned. Blacks people (journalists included) have allways had their own minds and thoughts when asked to express their points of views on any subject. Ms Schiavocampo is saying what the neocons and anti Obama supporter think. When people of color advance in a society that is constructed for them to fail the narrow minded people will look to make lies their reality. These people think a jury of Blacks people peers are a group of 12 Whites and a White judge.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Beate Kaebel, Stuttgart, Germany — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 09:18:32 GMT

I can only concur with some of the reader responses: Can whites report fairly when it comes to others? As it were, one has to expand this question: can white people report fairly on anybody? Stupid question, is it? So is the question whether black reporters can be unbiased when it comes to reporting on blacks. As usual, it all boils down to the individual, for, collectively speaking, in the collective Euro-American and, actually, generally white context, no matter where on this planet, we have been seeing a preponderance of unfair, biased, distorted reporting etc. for centuries. Guess we should first question that before we worry about black or any other bias...

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

joey — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 11:15:45 GMT

Ask bloody relevant questions you cheap-thrill seeking reporter! Is this how you think you'll climb your way to noteriety? Go work for the National Enquirer instead. Do you have reinforce in people's minds the notion that blacks mindlessly go by colour skin allegiance alone without any analytical thought process.....

It's this moronic line of thought you are indulging in that cost Clinton her election; First she pissed off her loyal black support by insulting them AND then to counter their switch to the more noble candidate Obama [not a skin loyalty based switch as the media sensationalized into being], Shrillary set out to rally latinos and 'hard-working' whites against her former support - her success in such divisive tactics is what's making the race between Obama and McCain closer than it should've been.

So once again- instead of grinning stupidly at these responses of outrage to your racially-demeaning idiocy, start writing compelling articles that lifts the complexity of your own thought process. With this article your reputation amongst peers is shallow and in the gutter. Rush Limbaugh must be applauding you and telling his audience of thick-headed stooges to read your article/query and saying "See -Even 'those people' say they professional journalists are being racist in favour of Obama".

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

POLpursun — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 11:22:09 GMT

The totality of the story of the U.S. (as opposed to the history ------ his-story ------ of the U.S.) demonstrates it Fuzzy Q. Jones. The pathological denial of that story, for instance, is at the base of why notions such as "an honest dialogue on race" will continue to be strongly resisted by the status quo.

Quite frankly, the question was answered "right out of the gate", albeit by inference. Indeed, every one of the answers, I opine, assumed that it was, in effect, a rhetorical question but provided effective answers anyway. I suspect that each respondent could have taken the path of silly question. I further suspect that the question was posed as one that's out there, with the full knowledge that it was, indeed, silly.

Finally, to take Mr. Mabry's notion one step further: Twice as good ---- to obtain half the deserved credit. Ah, but for thoroughbreds, on an individual level, that's just motivation, albeit that passivity as regards social injustices should be eschewed.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

kay — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 11:51:55 GMT

I agree with the fact that it all depends on the individual reporter. There's this African-American female republican analyst on CNN's "the campaign trail" who rips Obama apart every week with such relish....she certainly doesn't care that they are the same color, she just does her job (maybe too well).
Then there are the several grey haired, white, old men reporting glowingly about John McCain and knee-capping Obama every chance they get(Lou Dobbs, Jim Clancy to name a few). Could it be because they look like McCain.....hard to tell.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

William Gilliam, Emporia, KS — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 11:53:07 GMT

As a 55 year old Black man who is not a reporter, I believe that Black Journalist can be objective. However I also recognize that all journalist are not the same. That is. that Black journalist, like their White counterparts bring different interview skills to the table. Not everyone can be a Tim Russert and therfore the public will generally make judgements based on the talents of the interviewer, and attribute it to bias.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Milt Long, Conyers GA — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 13:08:36 GMT

The question should be "Can half-white, half-black reporters with a Muslim father and a Christian mother truly and honestly cover a politician of similar background." Perhaps a second question should be "Can a politician who has been imprisoned for years by an enemy of the US be an impartial president."

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Mary OK — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 13:48:06 GMT

I have yet to hear an African American pro Obama TV commenntator that his thin resume might give a person pause. I am not talking about his lack of experience-but his lack of significant contribution in any job he ever held. I live in Chicago, and from time to time come across African Americans who live in his neighborhood. They acknowledge that Obama never did too much for his community, that the content and tone of Rev. Wright's statements are well known in the communit - even by those who dont' attend the church - but I never hear pro - Obama Arican American commentators suggest that his vacuous and vapid work history may be a reason people may not vote for him - the assumption is that racism is at work.

I personnally would like to see the broad cast media have an open discussion of Obama's resume and discuss whether his contribution in any of positions outweights the benefit he has received from his position. I think we all know that He got more out of being a US Senator than the people of Illinois or the country. Having researched his work history carefully - I have concluded that it is the same in every job. Anyone who knows anything different I invite to post some specifics. Believe me, Obama has never exhibited an interst in governing in his elected positions and won't change as President.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

EMT East Coast — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 14:15:05 GMT

The issue ignored by the question and the responses is, 90% of the media, REGARDLESS of race, are not covering Obama fairly. They are completely in his camp and are using their positions to get him elected. Political donations by members of the mainstream media are 100:1 in favor of Democrats, and that was BEFORE this election.

White, black, purple with green polka dots- it doesn't matter what race the reporter is. The coverage is biased.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Arby, Seattle WA — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 14:31:47 GMT

I am sick to death of being labeled a racist because I am not voting for Barak Obama. It's obvious to me that the man simply does not have the qualifications to be president. A one term junior Senator from IL who has spent the last two years campaigning just doesn't have the experience to be commander in chief.

As to question about objectivity...you need not look any further than what happened to Tavis Smiley. I haven't found any negative reporting on Obama from a black journalist. Nor have I found any negative reporting on Obama from any liberal journalist. Prejudice and racism is alive and well in this country, but it goes both ways. When nearly 100% of blacks say they are voting for Obama and his white liberal supporters are calling anybody who questions his qualifications a bigot and a racist, then to me the question was not only fair it was quite relevant. And should have included whether liberal journalists can cover Obama objectively.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Dr. Yazdi — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 15:44:29 GMT

Can a white dentist fill a black man's tooth properly.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Arthur Ward, Chicago, Illinois — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 15:45:20 GMT

Sorry, every black person in America is multi-racial - so what do they mean when they say he has a white mother? I could safely estimate that at least one-third of the second generation of Africans born on this soil was the exact racial make-up as Senator Obama by the time the white slave traders and owners finished getting started with mixing it up with us. The only difference is that some of our families became mixed early in our history (98% of black people)and some of our families became mixed late in our history (Sen. Obama and others). So what are people meaning by this? Just a walk downtown during evening rush hour, and observing the widely different skin tones of black people reveals the obvious - there are no racially pure (African) black people in this country! Sen. Obama is truly one of us! If the senator was not whom he is and just walking down the street, he would not be assumed for anything other than an african-american. So it is difficult not to be biased! No more biased than Hannity, Limbaugh, The Weekly Standard - we can go on.

As far as Christianity is concerned - it is a philosophical perversion that has functioned as a millstone around the necks of black people since we were brought here. And we will never get our act together as a people until we get rid of clergymen, Jesus and christianity.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Josef, Montgomery, AL — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 15:57:45 GMT

when close to 95% of people of a long discriminated race support a candidate of the same race, when no such large plurality has been seen before for a candidate based on his/her positions it makes this (or a similar question) legitimate. And because of this country's history of racism, it is better to remove the emotional components from both sides by an AA reporter to ask it (though not required).
I.e. if 90% of women voted for Hillary, it would be a obvious conclusion that her gender was more important a consideration than her views, since no comparable disparity existed by women for a candidate previously.
However, the real question then becomes, WHY? And that is where journalists can examine the roots and the continuing issues that plague being black in america.
There are no easy answers, but we truly MUST look into this. Avoiding these discussions has not eased suspicion on those who believed race is the answer everywhere (from both sides). But, perhaps, we can now enter an era where we can examine what we do as groups, where it came from, and what we really want (ie. i do not believe 95%-one poll, i know, of african-americans WANT a black president as much as they WANT a system that is fair to all without regard to race. Hence, the overhwelming support for Bill Clinton, a white man believed to be fair, and now, Obama is that option from the choices. Add pride to the mix, and yes, a larger percentage of AA's can be expected to vote for him. That does not mean they are not fairly assessing him. Previous black candidates did not get this large a percentage of poll support from this group....so it IS about issues, wiht a little bit of other reasonable cause for support thrown in.
But, PLEASE. Let us continue to discuss this, without race talk being negative. We are different in many ways, but we are similar in more.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Lee,Precott Arizona — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 16:09:50 GMT

All questions are fair game especially when it comes to questioning the integrity of ALL journalsits, not just the black ones. How can a journalist expect me to believe they are objective when they identify themselves as a member of a race, ethnicity or polictical party? Those of us granted with the gift of sight can obviously surmise the origin of their family tree. What we need are the FACTS regarding the Candidates position on critical issues without the journalists pontificating their personal views on the subject. I can form my own opinions !!!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

E Gray Sanford, Florida — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 17:03:36 GMT

I concur with "Concerned, Il. I believe there are some journalists, whether they be black or white that do try to report the news fairly and unbiased, but there are some journalists that will say and do what they tld by those who control the purse strings; Yes, the Rich and Powerful, whose divide and conquer tactics has manage to cripple our government which is no longer for the people, but for the few. They turn race against race, cause confusion instead of understanding, and replaces hope with fear. If we could take greed and power not only out of politics, but out of the corporate board rooms, and out of our so called higher institutions of learning, Race would not be as big of an issue as it is today. That is not to say racism would'nt exist because some people would have a hard time letting it go regardless.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Anna, FL — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 18:18:19 GMT

How can anyone thing this question is irrelevant?

Someone asked, "When will this country finally be colorblind?" Probably never. But it will be far less important an issue when it is our eighth black president being voted in. Or our seventh Hispanic. Asian. Woman. Whenever a precedent is being set there is and will always be bias. For better or worse. If Barack Obama wins this election, I don't envy the time he will spend in the Whitehouse. Every move. Every vote and veto will be criticized and evaluated.

Anyone who likes to pretend there isn't still a racist undercurrent in this country needs to get off their high-horse. In one day I was called a N-loving traitor and a white-bred, racist b**** for voicing my moderate opinions on BOTH candidates weaknesses. That, my friends, is quite the juxtaposition. And while both of these instances lean toward extremist situations, they are figureheads of racial institutions on both sides of the fence that need to be diffused before we can exist in a "colorblind" society.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

CS, Owings Mills, MD — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 18:24:50 GMT

To me it makes a statement saying, "We need to do everything we can to get a black person in the Oval office." The problem? They are only trying to put a puppet in office. He is a well dressed, well spoken balck man, but his credintials for being Chief of our great country? it sucks!. Everyone knows what you do with a puppet. You get tired of it and get rid of it. I would like to know why Obama's campaign doesn't publish all the threats he has had against him. He needs to remember. This country has some crazy people in it. He is riding a media bubble right now, thinking that he can make everyone love him. My only statement to that? If you love him, you are blind. To make him President of this great country, would be the same as YOU going to a doctor that only has 2 years of medicine under his belt. It would only take one (1) wrong move to scar you for life. That is what I equate the 3 a.m. call at the White House. (Who would you want to answer the phone?) Everyone needs to take a deep breath and wait until this coming Thursday, August 31, 2008. Watch the media, then make your choice. Don't be blind sided by talk for a serpents tongue.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

H. Weaver — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 18:36:55 GMT

This was a silly question. This election cycle is Way too long or the reporters need to find more stories about other topics. Can a White cover a White? A Christian cover a Christian? A Truck Driver cover a Truck driver?...yeah this is SILLY.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Ken, Beaufort, SC — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 18:37:18 GMT

Black reporters are about as objective toward Obama as Fox News is towards Republicans. View the report with skepticism. Of course the same can be said about the entire mainstream news media. In 2000 they gave Bush a free ride. This time its Obama. Where is the coverage about him lying about his membership on the Senate banking committee? Guess a lie by their darling isn't important.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

insulted, indianapolis, in — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 19:17:21 GMT

Like majority have agreed, the question is dumb and unnecessary. I toatally agree with Fuzzy Q. Jones that the bigger question is can white journalist report on Obama fairly, like the poster of this ridiculous article Barbara Raab.
As for all the comments about the black journalists not answering the questions, it's obvious to me that the poster of this nonsense took posted their responses out of context.I guarantee these people were not asked the question "Can black reporters cover Obama fairly" and those were their immediate replies. She pulled selected statements that were made in regards to the topic and posted them as their answers.
So I ask again, can white reporters cover Obama fairly?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

A Wright, Peachtree Corners GA — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 19:39:51 GMT

A recent poll showed 94% of blacks supporting Obama and 1% supporting McCain. Someone please tell me of another group that has ever supported a candidate by such a margin........ It can't be done. That is why this question of black objectivity is being raised. The poll confirms what everyone, including poor Bill Clinton, have been saying all along - that all blacks support Obama. If this poll is even remotely correct then it can be safely assumed that all black reporters are Obama supporters. The same assumption cannot be made of white reporters because whites never support one candidate in such numbers. You might get 55% supporting one candidate, usually the GOP candidate. However, since roughly half of whites vote for each party you could make an argument that about half of all white reporters would vote for one candidate or the other. This is why there is a higher level of confidence that just because a reporter is white that they are not going to support one party or the other. The same cannot be said of black reporters in this instance. I think a more interesting story would be the danger of a voting bloc supporting one candidate in such monolithic numbers. It has some scary and dangerous undertones to it that I suspect most reporters are too scared to dig into it due to fear of being called a racist.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

LisaHussein — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 19:43:18 GMT

I will have to chime in to EMPHASIZE what several people have already said. In the racist world that we live in, we (African Americans) need to stop walking on eggshells and trying to please white folks. We need to concentrate on pleasing God and then ourselves - if the others are pleased too - great. I have YET to see consistent UNBIASED coverage by the MSM on Obama - YET. Take a look back at the coverage: ABC folly of a debate, questioning his patriotism - he has to wear a flag an no one else does?!?, questioning his religious beliefs (do the others EVEN GO TO CHURCH) questioning Mrs. Obama's patriotism, and let's not forget the terrorist fist jab, and Obama's baby mama. I could go on and on. So if we are biased it will only LEVEL the playing field!!!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Susan — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 19:45:09 GMT

To anotherperspective, thank you.

It isn't a ridiculous question. In fact, it is a very legitimate and important question.

What we are witnessing is unique. Black journalists reporting on a black candidate that will more than likely become our first black President. How can they not be swept up in the fanfare and the excitement they feel? You cannot ignore who they are covering and to ignore color in this case, is unfair. Being white, I celebrate the history being made today!

Do white candidates report fairly on white candidates? Not always! Journalists are human beings and as such, it is impossible not to bring human emotion and personal feelings in to their story.

Look back at white journalists of the past. Walter Cronkite, David R Murrow, David Brinkley, the list goes on. All of these men reported the news but you still saw a bit of their personal opinion creep into their reporting.

I don't know of any objective reporting today. In our world of today, everyone has an opinion and as such, they express it either through words or actions.

Hopefully, in the future, it won't be an issue. But today, it is an issue for all of us to embrace. Questions and all.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

John Dough, Baltimore, Maryland — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 19:57:47 GMT

Do FOX/CBS/NBC/ABC News reporters cover everyone fairly? The premise of this blog is so ridiculous. What factors would you use to measure bias?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Mike Carter, Gates, Oregon — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 20:02:00 GMT

All in all, there may be some validity to the whole question. I started out wondering why black journalists were being asked if they could be professional. Why should color be a reason for questioning professionalism? But as I read through the comments, I could see some level of reality. The question is not so much that black journalists may be less than objective, or that female journalists were/are not objective on female candidates, or that privately neocon journalists were giving McCain a free ride, but how to deal with what seem to be accepted assumptions that an individual jounalist's gender, race, political alignment or whatever will automatically color what they write. After that needlessly long sentence, what we may want be concerned about are some of the current perceptions of journalism itself. The borderline between pundit and publicist has blurred beyond recognition. Legitimate candidates line up for the "bump" of a faux interview with an actor who performs a caricature of a biased commentator no one would ever confuse with a legitimate journalist. In sum, we live in a world where every journalist has to deal with a public that assumes they have a personal agenda, and does not assume that they are professional enough to rise above it.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Regina, St. Petersburg, FL — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 20:23:57 GMT

I believe that the majority of black people are supporting Obama because he is intelligent, tolerant of other cultures and beliefs, eloquent speaker, and is more aligned with their beliefs. I believe we are not supporting McCain because he is not an eloquent speaker, he is prone to outbursts, and historically has not supported the issues that are importance to the black community. Thus, it is a no-brainer that Obama would get the majority of the black vote. I want a president I can be proud of and unfortunately McCain just doesn't fit that bill. He is constantly mispeaking on issues he should be well versed on and openly admits that he is not informed on issues that a candidate running for president should be informed on. Especially if he voted on the issues in the Senate.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Ty Seattle, Wash. — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 20:38:17 GMT

This is the most assinine article I have ever read. She is stupid for even asking the question. Probably a GOP Plant Sally...

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Caryl, Pembroke Pines, Florida — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 21:03:34 GMT

With the exception of Juan Williams, black journalists have shown unwavering bias in favor of Obama. Similarly, black voters turned their backs on Hillary, who had always been in their corner, and is vastly better qualified. It is irresponsible and short-sighted to put an inexperienced, unqualified candidate in the awesome position of President of the United States. Obama can demonstrate his courage and leadership by NOMINATING HILLARY AT THE CONVENTION. Perhaps, after two terms as HER VP, he will have earned the trust of the voters. But he is simply not electable in '08 and I am weary of hearing that our objects are his race!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

al johnson-646, Baltimore, Md — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 21:07:22 GMT

I find it quite interesting that this question would even come up. I thought a journalist was to report the facts. Personal opinions, subjection, etc. was to be kept out of the article. I believe the question poised by the reporter is insulting. To Real Deal and Others - Don't apply your logic to everyone else. My wife and several of my family members will not vote for Obama, nor will they vote for McCain. They all have said they will vote for local candidates. Don't believe that all Black folks vote in a block. When the repubs have something to offer, they will get the Black vote. Our state has had several GOP Governors, and the state is at least 75% democratic. Black people vote their interest, whether its Democrats or Repub. You can now see why the Black community did not overwhelmingly vote for Bush, this guy is a disaster as President. And McCain gives off this aura, stiff, lying, and unconcerned. So if Obama is getting as you say 90% of the Black vote, its because he is more convincing.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Kristopher Lawrence, Parker, Co — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 21:14:00 GMT

Its kind of funny how everyone starts there comment with "This question is ridiculous" then they answer it. Anyways I think this question is legit. Despite how disturbing it might be, its a question that should be answered with the utmost honesty, and not the answer that most people want to hear. Using the past as an excuse for white reporters doesn't really cut it. We can't condemn people of the past for the their biased or unbiased reporting, so lets look to the present. Its the first racially mixed human being ever to run, so in my opinion a lot of new and disturbing questions will arise. I am also mixed with white and black, and I feel anyone running for office or what not should be prepared..

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Len Obregon — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 21:47:42 GMT

The reason this is very relevant is because Obama received over 90% of the black vote against HRC. She has a 25 year history of strong support for civil rights etc. etc. and her husband received over 90% of the black vote in two elections. Yet despite this record black voters overwhelmingly chose Obama purely on racial grounds since there were virtually no real policy differences between them

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Joe Zollo, Princeton, NJ — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 21:50:00 GMT

There are no black "reporters" or "white reporters" or ""brown" yellow and red; there are no longer any reporters ... ALL of them are editorial writers and slant every story, edit every picture, place every piece of a photo-op on air to fit their own agenda.
That agenda might be conservative, liberal, or whatever, but it is NEVER neutral! It's like asking Pelosi to cover the republican convention and as her to make comparisons with the democrat convention...surprise surprise what she would say!

Someone earlier said this question was dumb... I think it is not an oxymoron....just plain moronic.

Over 90% of the blacks are voting for Obama...and that's not racist...that is just appreciating the mans resume' and ability to do the job. Give me a break!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Sam, Sacto, CA — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 22:04:07 GMT

This question is obviously a non-issue. If reporters weren't able to set aside their personal views, whatever those views ma be, they wouldn't last long in their business. And for everyone wanting to kill whitey, remember that this question was asked by a black woman. Let's leave the race-baiting out of this and try to hold ourselves to a higher standard.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Steve Day — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 22:34:52 GMT

The answer is NO. But not because they are black and he is (half) black. But because journalists can't cover anyone "fairly", as people are interpreting the question. They can cover him objectively from their personal history and background complete with their opinions.
But that does not mean that they should not cover him. White conservative reporters can't cover John McCain "fairly". They can and should do their jobs as well as they can. If they are reporting his activities, then that is what they should do. If they are Editorializing (is that a real word?), then they should state their position clearly.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Gary Ackerman Ocala, Fl — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 22:35:27 GMT

The question of whether or not Black journalists can report unbiased on Obama, should also carry a caveat, OF;;Can White journalists report unbiased for McCain. Either way the questions are ridiculous. Maybe the person posing the initial question is them self biased for even considering such a stupid "question".

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jim De. — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 22:37:29 GMT

Of course black reporters and blacks in general are going to vote for a black candidate. It doen't matter if he's qualified or not..He's black and in their way of thinking that is all that matters. It has been proven time and time again.Look at Marian Berry in Washington, look at Jack Ellis in Macon,Ga. These two mayors were guilty of many criminal charges, but because the voting base was predominately black they kept getting voted back into office.(Because they were black) there was no positive reasons to vote for them. They were black..

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

LB, Newport News, VA — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 22:51:14 GMT

I think the better question is can "white reporters" report on him without bias. They stalk him constantly looking for the rare gaffe, while Sen. McCain makes them daily and they miss them or ignore them because, they are so busy waiting for Sen. Obama to slip up. I also wish the white reporters would stop insinuating that the confidence that Sen. Obama shows, is his being presumptuous or even arrogant. African Americans can be confident without being "UPPITY".

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

LTC Larry D. Jones Decatur, Al — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 22:56:18 GMT

As a retired officer and a proud American that happens to be black; I agree that not one reporter answered the question. We all know that for the first time in our nations history we have the chance to elect our nations first President of color. I know Senator Obama Labels himsrlf as multiracial but in the eyes of so many Americans he is a Black man. I for one am tired of the press writting a clearly biased article about some one or something in this country and then hiding behind they are only being an objective journalist argument. I have never understood why they just can't say hey I just don't like this guy and the way he thinks. I for one am not a supporter of Senator Obama and I am not excited about John Mccain. I know that leadership is not just about ability, experience,and the ability to size up a situation and make the right choice. Leadership is a mixture of all of those traits and others.Quit worrying about how we as black Americans are being judged over how they report on a candidate because of their race; and start looking at the fact that no matter who is elected we will be making a choice that will directly impact this nation forever.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

The Coloured European Observer — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 23:06:14 GMT

"As for about 92% of blacks voting for Obama"
I just wanna know WHAT DA F the other 8 percent is thinking?!?! ;)
Asking the question is proof of how much blacks have internalized racism against THEMSELVES. Also for blacks, it apparently takes some effort to think of ourselves as levelheaded, reasonable, detached etc, etc. all the 'good' attributes we ascribe to Whitey McWhite.

Oh, and that loser that described Uncle Tom as the HERO of the book: You REALLY must be drinking the Kool-Aid, and did NOT get ANYthing about that book.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

SealTeam 0 — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 23:06:27 GMT

I must agree with the earlier comment, that it would be more to the point to ask if white journalists ARE (not would) report without bias against Obama. It has been demonstrated that many already show their racist flavoring in the editorialized reporting that we are now getting. The article titles and the cynical pundancy around every statement or movement of Obama is so obvious that Stevie Wonder can see it.

And with regard to a black woman posing the question, who do you think would lend more legitimacy to an undercover racist attack than to put "Ole Uncle Remus" out front? Conservative, corporate run news outlets have never had a problem finding a Clarence Thomas when they want to incite division within the black community. The only problem is that blacks fall for it. So, I encourage Black Journalist to keep on doing the fine job of representing balanced visual landscape as well as perspective. If white newscasters can report in a way that they feel appeals to their pro-white audiences, shouldn't it be at least as fair for blacks(when they get that rare, on camera moment) to throw a little weight to the other side of the issues and viewpoints?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

The Coloured European Observer — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 23:07:19 GMT

in 1960, did they ask this of Catholic reporters?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Kenny,Frankfort,Ky — Sat, 26 Jul 2008 23:16:44 GMT

Can white journalists cover McCain fairly?Can any journalist cover ANY candidate without mixing in their or their employers views?Ridiculous question!!!
For the record I am white.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Bob,Virginia Beach,Va. — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 00:09:25 GMT

Black People are MORE racist than whites.lol What would happen if we had a "WHITE" entertainment network?And what do white people say about the Black entertainment network? Wake up people..No one wants to actually say it and it prolly has a LOT to do with Education BUT..There is a lot more Ignorance among Blacks than Whites..There..I said it ..Sorry if the Truth Hurts

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Fuzzy Q. Jones, Centennial, CO — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 00:43:16 GMT

Reply to P: Contrary to your opinion and others, Black Africans learned about the Good News of Jesus of Nazareth before the trans-atlantic diaspora. Read the following:

Philip and the Ethiopian

26Now an angel of the Lord said to Philip, "Go south to the road—the desert road—that goes down from Jerusalem to Gaza." 27So he started out, and on his way he met an Ethiopian[a]eunuch, an important official in charge of all the treasury of Candace, queen of the Ethiopians. This man had gone to Jerusalem to worship, 28and on his way home was sitting in his chariot reading the book of Isaiah the prophet. 29The Spirit told Philip, "Go to that chariot and stay near it."

30Then Philip ran up to the chariot and heard the man reading Isaiah the prophet. "Do you understand what you are reading?" Philip asked.

31"How can I," he said, "unless someone explains it to me?" So he invited Philip to come up and sit with him.

32The eunuch was reading this passage of Scripture:
"He was led like a sheep to the slaughter,
and as a lamb before the shearer is silent,
so he did not open his mouth.
33In his humiliation he was deprived of justice.
Who can speak of his descendants?
For his life was taken from the earth."[b]

34The eunuch asked Philip, "Tell me, please, who is the prophet talking about, himself or someone else?" 35Then Philip began with that very passage of Scripture and told him the good news about Jesus.

36As they traveled along the road, they came to some water and the eunuch said, "Look, here is water. Why shouldn't I be baptized?"[c] 38And he gave orders to stop the chariot. Then both Philip and the eunuch went down into the water and Philip baptized him. 39When they came up out of the water, the Spirit of the Lord suddenly took Philip away, and the eunuch did not see him again, but went on his way rejoicing.

Acts 8:26-39 (NIV)

Yes, Christianity was perverted by the slaveowners to justify their barbarity, and perverted by the white supremacists to justify segregation. But the call to end these unjust systems came from Christians, some Christians, but certainly not all Christians. The African American Christians were clearly at the forefront of the abolitionist and desegregation movements, i.e. Richard Allen, Frederick Douglass, Sojourner Truth, Ida B. Wells, Henry McNeil Turner, and most certainly Martin Luther King, Jr.

Just as Black Africans and African Americans suffered under European Christians, they suffered under Arab Muslims, and still do in places like Mauritania and Sudan. The Arabs have preyed on Black Africans for centuries as a source of slaves. I could never understand why the Nation of Islam advocated the adoption of Arab names for its members, like "Muhammad". I could understand African names but not Arab names for people of African descent perhaps that is the real reason why Malcolm Little, became Malcolm X. He claimed that "Little" was his slave name but I think he realized that "Muhammad Ali" was equally a slave name, although from a different ethnic and religious source.

The sad truth is that Black Africans or African Americans have found no pure and encompassing comfort from other ethnic groups (Asian, Arab, Hispanic, Native American, White, etc.) or religions (Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhaism, etc.). One of the leading critics of African Americans is Dinesh D'Souza an immigrant from India who claims Christianity as his religion, read the "The End of Racism".

Just as Jews and Christians have vastly different interpretations of the Old Testatament, the former claims it describes the arrival of a messiah yet to come, and the latter thinks it describes the arrival of a messiah who came, died, resurrected and ascended to heaven and is returning a second time; African American Christians and White American Christians interpret the same Bible differently when it comes to moral law, racial matters and social justice.It is that difference that nurtures, preserves, and inspires African Americans, our heritage so to speak. White Christians under the guise of "integration" now want to destroy the Black Church in America to rip that heritage away from us.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Linda Reynolds New York, NY — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 01:21:43 GMT

I question whether many journalists can treat any issue objectively these days. The whole concept of journalism has gotten muddied by the proliferation of cable "news" and talking head pundits. I don't know if there are any real journalists left. I thought the coverage of Clinton was deplorable, by the way, from black and white "journalists" and it seems McCain is getting a free pass on "journalists" asking hard questions, just like GW Bush has gotten away with murder, literally for eight years plus (including his candidacy).

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Harold Land New York, NY — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 01:29:29 GMT

Phyllis Kunz--your name sounds like the name McCain called his wife as reported in the book The Real McCain. You should read it and find out wht a nut job he really is. But go ahead and write in Bush. Thank God, all you lunatic Bush supporters, in the face of all evidence, will not be able to damn the rest of us with another term with that psycopath.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Dominic Chester, Va — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 02:29:45 GMT

I think that they can. I think that they have already had plenty of practice covering other black politicians and public figures. I think that it's a mistake to think that all black people have the same agenda or that we have a few people in public life that speak for the whole race. My God the various opinions in my own extended family at times have been so heated that we rarely discuss our political views at family gatherings anymore. Folkes there is no BLACK AGENDA. Most of us want the very same things that all other Americans want. A safe place to live, Good neighbors, goood schools, a great job and to live the Amreican dream. Sure there are some of us who feel that there were in justices that should be corrected through reperations an other such nonsense. their are those of us who are just a prejudice as the, for lack of a better word, Red Neck (hope i'm using that term correctly) and there are people like me who just want to live and love and be successful. I'm so very thankful for my mixed community and work place. We all get along very well and hang out together even theough we have different views on, namew a subject, but we respect on another and laugh and talk and look outg for each other here in Chester, Va. and I love it...I think that it's the best place to live in the world. Which is why I still drive 125mi daily to work in Washington DC and refuse to move from the great community. I only wish that the rest of you could enjoy the life that I have with the grest people whom surround me. I would be proud if Obama bacame president and was successful in bringing prosperity back to this country instead of sending all of my Tax dollars overseas. There are many people in this country who are suffering. Especially in the south and Upstate NY, Michigan, Ohio etc. We are not on equal footing with the rest of the world when it comes to educating ourselves and that has to change. We have private business taking advantage of those of us who have so little when all we expect is to be treated fairly and with honesty. The average American can not be expected to understand a legal document or hire a lawyer everytime we sign something. I understand that we need to let the free market work, but we need to protect the under educated or just the person who desides to lead the simple life. We all know that those who rebel against public education probably have the resources to have their own children educated privately, but we all have to realize that uneducated people are usually the ones who violently victimize the rest of us when times are hard. I Love this country even with it's flaws and I hope that you do to and if it wasn't apparent in the beginning I am black,

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Wayne Shover, Fredericksburg, Virginia — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 02:40:33 GMT

I dont think there are too many black or women conservative journalists as compared to white male journalist. I think bias is based on ideology rather than race.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

ron louisville ky — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 02:49:20 GMT

can white hillbilly rednecks judge obama fairly?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

John, Collegeville, PA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 03:10:49 GMT

I've been thinking about this one. Given that Obama enjoys something like 94% support among blacks, it's basically a given that a black reporter favors Obama. Knowing that, you can't help but wonder and watch for nuance and suggestion in their reporting, even if it's unintentional. Even if a reporter does something subtle, like smiling when talking about one candidate vs. not smiling about the other, it can have a big effect on the viewers (If I remember my psychology classes, there was a study of the Reagan/Carter election which showed that reporters smiled significantly more when talking about one candidate. Another study measured the impact of smiling when giving the same basic message. The results of the study were that even subtle things have an impact.). What to do about it, I don't know... but it is an issue

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Diane Lee — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 03:27:36 GMT

When a group of people first identifies themselves by their color and then as Americans - that alone makes this a good question. Frankly, I don't think any journalist of any color is able to report anything without lining it up with their own views and feelings. And their have been politicians who have said even though they don't agree with his policies or the fact that he is so libral - they support him because he is black... hmmmmmm.....

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Linda Porter, Atlanta, GA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 03:58:33 GMT

This question represents a non-issue! And I see they had a stupid black woman ask it. Chuck Todd, Andrea Mitchell, Kati Couric, et.al have been extremely biased in their coverage of Obama. Couric's coverage of McCain involved her reporting her verbatim question to McCain, deleting his answer and inserting an attack McCain made on Obama that had nothing at all to do with her question. So why not ask her about her bias instead of impugning the integrity of every Black journalist on the planet? After all, she has proven her bias.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

K.L., MO — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 04:43:31 GMT

Can anyone, any of us, claim true objectivity?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Noah's Dove, Oakland, CA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 05:28:13 GMT

This whole conversation has me on the verge of losing my dinner!

America likes to hide behind the stars and stripes and pretend we are all united under GOD. It's such a load.

As a black man who is supporting Obama, I find it offensive, that the automatic assumption is that I am operating off of "emotion" and not "critical thinking".

I was frankly leaning towards Clinton until she went nuts after losing Super Tuesday. Clinton seemed to believe that she was the Democratic heir apparent. After Obama took the lead she didn't have a contingency plan for how to proceed. I don't think I really want a chief executive who doesn't know what to do after something fails to pan out as anticipated. The jacked comments from Bill and the growing desperation of her campaign did not help.

So then and only then did I start to look towards Obama. One thing I really like about him is he always has a plan B or even C when his campaign strategies don't go as planned. He seems cool headed and measured (except when you attack his family; which he needs to get over since he is a public figure).

As far as this posting goes, I think it is telling that so many people are quick to point out that he is of "mixed race". This may be the case but he is perceived at best as non-white i.e. a person of color. Maybe that means black reporters will only be half as biased? That may sound ridiculous but this whole argument is foolish and yet necessary.

We live in a racist society and whether you are Black, White, Hispanic, Asian (yes other races than B&W exist in America) etc. it will play a part in how you vote.

I believe some whites will vote for him because they believe he is the right choice, others are voting off of white guilt maybe. Some blacks will vote for that black candidate but many will vote for the candidate they think best.

Believe it or not some blacks will not vote for Obama because they fear it would lead to his assassination. There are tons of articles about this.

Yes, this question was posted by a black woman. And it needed to be asked as stupid as it is. She knows what all people of color know-- we are never on the same footing as white people because we do not make the rules. It is important to "check ourselves" before they do, and they will.

The fact that so many posts state that white journalist have not been questioned about their objectivity of white candidates is odd. This is the first time a serious non-white candidate has made a bid for the white house. In the past, race was irrelevant because it was assumed that our leader would be a white man. The question would not have been nonsensical.

All and all I think this country is too worried about being PC which is just a mask and too touchy about race, gender, sexual orientation and religion! We really need to consider getting over ourselves :-)

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

John Johnson — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 05:45:25 GMT

This question just goes to prove how far we need to go. I saw an article the other day that suggested an Obama win would be a bad thing for black people. What would a win by McCain do for black people. The media is setting the bar too high for Obama, while giving McCain a hall pass.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Vogel, Tampa, Fl. — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 05:45:33 GMT

As a Native American / Caucasian I would like to point out that this article was written by an Africa American. Of course it is ridiculous to think about this bias, but keep in mind that Obama has MANY white supporters. Where I live I have friends of every race, and many of which support Obama. Reporters are typically going to report on stories that they BELIEVE in when it comes to politics, and good for them. We should ALL stand up for what we believe to be true and just. This race should not be about RACE, but about who can help our struggling nation become what it is capable of... A nation that TRULY is based upon equality for EVERYONE. Barack is both white and black, as I am Native American and white... We are a culture that is mixed, and we must EMBRACE our diversity as it is what makes us the great nation that we are today. I am truly proud to be an American, and we need to work TOGETHER to make America what it CAN be.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

chris nichols Middle river maryland — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 10:18:14 GMT

How long did you have to think about this silly question? It is insulting to all readers and americans. quit with the race card.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Sean Zackson — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 11:03:49 GMT

Of course a black reporter CAN cover a black candidate for President fairly. The only question I asked myself when I read the topic was 'WILL they cover it fairly'? That's where the dividing line falls between a journalist and a typical reporter. I am hoping there are more journalists.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

rvsodders,industry,pa. — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 11:18:33 GMT

lets be honest folks,if your black,your backing Obama,its as simple as that.Here's a man that talks good but has no idea what he is talking about.If this man gets in office,and you think the problem with all the blacks and illegal immigrants is bad now,just wait.

GOD HELP US.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

RHW Washington, DC — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 11:40:49 GMT

The reason this really stupid question is being asked in the first place is because the answer is a resounding "NO." Most african-americans know very little, if anything at all, about obama - they don't care. African-americans who support obama do so mainly because he's black. That's it! Black journalist should be telling the real story of obama and exposing his underside to african-americans. Instead, they too are on the obamamania bandwagon - feeling and thinking as though it has become their duty to "protect" america's black candidate for president. obama is using the black community. These black journalist should be telling that story. Jeese Jackson has it right.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

AC Robertson, Newport, NC — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 12:47:10 GMT

There are few if any reporters that do not slant the news. Never think that one source of information is ever going to be the whole truth.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

white girl, small town USA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 13:01:54 GMT

At what point do we stop looking at race and gender and just consider the facts that are given? who would make the president for "OUR" country? Remember "United we stand, Divided we fall" I think "OUR" country is falling fast!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Sun, 27 Jul 2008 15:22:19 GMT

No, they can't. Black journalists are like any other journalists, that is, they report their stories with an eye toward keeping African Americans in the spotlight, regardless of how militant they African Americans act. Only this year at this time, the stakes are much, much greater and carry with them the potential to tear this country apart.
M, Austin, Texas

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Berry Mountain — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 16:22:18 GMT

I blog quite frequently. I consider myself "conservative" but not necessarily a Republican. For me, it's about a candidates views on the issues, and the candidate's connections to corruption.

I noticed on the AOL BLOG early on, people making it clear that they were black, literally threating others on the blog. This blew me away.

I would never elect anyone based on their race, or gender and won't play the "politically correct" game with anyone.

For me, it's about the honesty (or dishonesty) of those I vote for. I see Obama has ties to corruption, and so does McCain...

As far as "black reporters" giving Obama favorable or preferrable reporting, yeah...I think that is happening somewhat. It's not going to make a bit of difference to me though.

I'm going to cast my vote in November for which person seems the most honest. After all, the PROMISES they make now, will be kept...or not kept in the future.

FYI: Bush ought to be imprisoned along with his CORRUPT CRONIES! I VOTED FOR BUSH TWICE, and yet wonder if Kerry really would have been better. Who knows.

The Clinton's are "THIEVES IN THE NIGHT." So, the closer Obama is to them, the closer I am to voting for McCain who is also CORRUPT.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Grae — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 16:52:19 GMT

I have a question: If this is a 'Unity' conference then why are there no 'white's'? There are African/Asian/Hispanic/Native Americans but no white Americans? Doesn't sound like a 'unity' conference at all. To be true to it's name then ALL should be included.
As far as the topic, it's absurd, why is race even being brought up? It's just another way to divide us. As is this so called unity conference.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Bob, Atlanta, Ga — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 16:57:11 GMT

Ed Smith,

Can a white journalist be objective and stick to the facts and hold John McCain to the same standards that they set for Barack Obama? Now why didn't you ask that question? I think your question is very telling to where your own head is.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

mike — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 17:56:16 GMT

whites do not vote as a block. I guess blacks can't be fair. Over 85% of blacks will vote for b.o. Sounds fair to me

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Vanna Jordan — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 18:30:33 GMT

My question is rethorical, "Can white reporters report on potential "white" candidates objectively?"

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Dele, Atlanta, GA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 18:55:17 GMT

I've found that reading the comments on this topic was far more interesting than the topic itself! As a black woman, I felt proud that we had serious black (really bi-racial) and female presidential candidates. I am insulted by the clear double standard that exists with regard to people of color (the same double standard that would make someone think it's ok to question black reporters' objectivity and not that of white ones). However, I admit this is a moment to which most white people cannot relate because they're so used to seeing people who look like them in power that they don't notice it anymore. Therefore, I think that if questions like this are posed, it should be part of a larger conversation acknowledging this country's complicated and uncomfortable history regarding race.

To respond to a couple of misinformed comments:

Joey from Baltimore states that he hopes Obama wins so black people can stop using racism as an "excuse" for affirmative action and other "welfare." White people like Joey have benefited from this very same racism (whether they've been complicit in it or not) and are off base when accusing all blacks of trying to use race to gain the privileges they (whites) take for granted. I'd love to see someone commission a study to determine the financial cost of slavery and racism on black Americans compared to the financial benefits whites have received over the years by stealing black people's labor and ideas and not having to compete against blacks. Then maybe white people like Joey can stop pretending racism ended with slavery or that its effects are a figment of black people's imaginations.

To EZquick and others' comments about the percentage of blacks voting for Obama, I'm SO sick of hearing this argument! When Obama first came on the scene, the vast majority of black Democrats supported Hilary Clinton and didn't give Obama the time of day; back then he was just as black as he is today and no one remarked on the LACK of support he received from people who look like him. Now that Hilary Clinton squandered the support of the black community and Obama proved himself to be a more than capable opponent, black people are suddenly supporting him ONLY because he's black. I also would love to hear more of these same haters talk about the percentage of white people who've admitted they WON'T vote for Obama simply because he's black (which means they're voting for their candidate simply because he's white). So I guess that argument cuts both ways...

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Cracker Jack, Mofo, Alabama — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 19:49:29 GMT

The question can not be answered honestly by black reporters, but the facts are obvious, these people would support any incompetent, inexperienced blowhard with black skin. They are totally biased and want a black president so bad that hey would sell out the rest of the country to get what they want. This is racism at it's worst. Be careful what you wish for, it might not really be so great after all.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Jhon Doe, seattle, wash. — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 19:52:04 GMT

my prayer for our future President that GOD in his grace will keep satan away from him and his family since satan have his own in all color shape and height may GOD release his people his way and restraint all satan's own.jealousy, hate, killing, no evil comes from GOD but satan any heart that contains any of this horrible ways must and will stay away from GOD'S work. the future president went to Israel wrote his humble prayer to his LORD satan earase it because in all the prayers there that was the only prayer in that wall GOD honoured.I saw it I cried because that is my prayer for him whenever GOD brings his name to my heart.He is blessed my heart loves him.his smile is so genuine make all good hearts smile too.the whole family are true American GOD uses America for all great stuff.it's like GOD cannot trust no other country or people to do spiritual things but America, that's the place where King Jesus reigns. I love this country

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

juanita santana, b'ham, al — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 19:52:39 GMT

Forget, the question I want to comment on the response from Phyllis Kunz..KY...she states President Bush is the greatest President and she might write his name. Le me count he ways...we're still at war in IRA (a country that had nothing to do with 9/11 was no imminent threat to us), we're still at war in Afghanistan (with not enough troops in country/that borders the country that planned/executed the attack on 9/11), the economy is in shambles,food prices are on the rise, the housing market is unstable, the banking industry is in trouble(Wachovia just announced lay offs of 6500 people) and you think Bush is the greatest President ever...surely you jest. Or could you provide some fact to support that premise. As far as OBama acting like the President...the man gave a speech, I did not hear any specific policy proposals in Germany..just a speech about the need to work together. I believe McCain gave a couple of speeches and press conferences during his overseas visits as well. As far as the press coverage, the OBama folks invited the press , McCain did not. As far as the question, I would assume that like any professional (whether black, cuacasian, hispanic, mediterranean, etc)when convering someone of your ethnicity, you make every effort to be fair and truthful when making reports

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

DeDe, Alabama — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 20:09:07 GMT

Does anyone remember that Obama is half white as well????????????

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Wayne , Orlando Florida — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 20:19:34 GMT

one thing that we are forgetting here is that I believe that Black journalist like any other Journalists can cover Obama fairly.. facts are facts in reporting but.. like many other things about reporting Blacks like whites can (key word here) choose which facts that get attention. for many black people watching history being made it its with a sense of pride that we watch Obama march to the white house whether we voted for him or not how many times has this happened before if this were a hispanic candidate the same would be said Sense of Pride but then after the "dust settles" it back to reporting the facts and I believe that black journalist can do that as well as any other Journalist out there. don't find fault in blacks because we feel proud of a black man attaining this goal if you voted for him or not. Now.. as far as his policies goes that is were the debate lives

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Pamela Reed, Perris CA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 20:48:49 GMT

I do not know the answer to that question but I have two of my own; can white journalists cover McCain fairly and can white journalists cover Obama fairly?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Helen, Broadus, MT. — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 21:15:47 GMT

Why should this question be asked as Obama is not only black but also white, but we are all created by God and we are all brothers and sisters. I am white and a woman,but I feared the the idea of a woman being president not the idea of a black. The Republican reporters, report on republicans no question asked; Democrat reporters report on Democracts no questions asked. Why are the questions being asked about Black Reporters. We are all CREATED EQUAL!!!!

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

ERW Houston, TX — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 21:23:31 GMT

After reading about some of the recent media coverage of Obama's trip abroad, including the questions asked by Couric, Williams, Brokaw et al. The question perhaps should be: can white journalists do a "fair" job of reporting on Obama.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Kyt, Tacoma, WA — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 22:05:23 GMT

Can and do White reporters cover Obama fairly?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Verin Paddock, Crested Butte, CO — Sun, 27 Jul 2008 23:34:14 GMT

IF the question is can.......all reporters can. If the question if MAY ......it depends on the network and why they were hired!

Verin......Crested Butte, Co

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

John, PA — Mon, 28 Jul 2008 00:30:35 GMT

What concerns me most is the concept the Johnathan Rodgers' Channel One TV will be covering the Democratic convention because Obama is black. What kind of reaction would we get if a cable network chose solely to cover the GOP convention because McCain is white?

I have no doubt that a journalist can put aside his or her feelings to cover a story fairly, regardless of race or any other consideration. But a corporate decision like that made by Rodgers smacks of...dare I say it?...racism.

Sorry, folks...but that's exactly what it is.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Joseph Williams, Adelphi, MD — Mon, 28 Jul 2008 13:51:44 GMT

Can Black journalists cover Obama in an unbiased way?
Can they do that?
Yes... Yes we can!

Oops!

But seriously, was this question asked of white Roman Catholic journalists covering the JFK, RFK and Ted Kennedy?

Or "born-again" reporters covering Jimmy Carter?

Can the same be said of a Black journalists reporting on David Duke?

Again, resoundingly. Yes they can!

A good journalist will keep his/her objectivity.

Unless your some PR Flack like Armstrong Williams, or a columnist with an agenda, like Peggy Noonan or Broder of the Wash. Post.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Arthur Ward, Chicago, Illinois — Mon, 28 Jul 2008 16:29:58 GMT

To DeDe in Alabama - pick up a history book please! African-American racial genetics range from 10% to 90% white. Look around the neighborhood at the range of skin tones, hair textures, features etc. The only difference is that some of us were mixed early in our family history in America (most black people) and some of us were mixed late in our family history (Obama and others) so he is definetely African-American, but without the european last name(s) that were "gifted" to the majority of our great-grandparents without their permission (Jones, Jackson, Williams and so on).

I am 52 years old - and I have never seen one instance where white people behaved "fairly" when it came to politics. If fairness from whites were the norm we would not have had to waste time and ink on civil rights laws, voting rights laws (in America?), or having to listen to certain politicians at one time in our history accusing some people of being communists because they expouse the notion of black people using their right to vote and hold office.

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Steve, Cleveland, Ohio — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 02:49:24 GMT

By now, many of you have seen the question answered by the over-the-top behavior of the minority media who gave Obama a standing ovation, rushed the stage for photos and applauded his remarks. Can there be any doubt left that the cards are stacked against McCain when it comes to getting fair and equal coverage from minority reporters?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

Arthur Ward, Chicago, IL — Wed, 30 Jul 2008 07:12:26 GMT

Reporter - the next question you should ask is can we have an election without all the religious talk. I really don't care what religion a candidate is. The constitution has an explicit prohibition on putting a candidate through a religious test. It seems like a big chunk of what the candidates have to tell us is christian belief related. I want to know how the candidate feels about the issues - not all this religious mess.

Could a non-christian be elected to be POTUS?

Can black journalists cover Obama fairly?

FuzzyQJones, Centennial, CO — Sun, 03 Aug 2008 23:44:29 GMT

Regarding the matter of bloc voting referred to by other bloggers:

"In Why We Can't Wait I wrote at length of the need for Negroes to unite for political action in order to compel the majority to listen. I urged the development of political awareness and strength in the Negro community, the election of blacks to key positions, and the use of the bloc vote to liberalize the political climate and achieve our just aspirations for freedom and human dignity."

Where Do We Go From Here? 1963, by Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr.