ABOUT THIS BLOG

The Daily Nightly began on May 31, 2005. As Brian wrote in his first post it aims to provide a narrative of the broadcast day and a window into the editorial process at NBC Nightly News. Brian weighs in every weekday and NBC News correspondents and producers post regularly.

Brian Williams became the seventh anchor and managing editor in the history of NBC Nightly News on December 2, 2004. Read his full biography.



The lionfish

Posted: Monday, June 30, 2008 4:13 PM by Sam Singal

By Michelle Kosinski, NBC News correspondent

A few weeks ago, on a flight over the Pacific, I was surprised to be handed a menu-- with a gleaming photo of a lionfish on the cover. It wasn't actually ON the menu that night, but it reminded us that the formidable fish with the mane of poisonous spines and a seemingly boundless appetite of its own, is actually a food item on the other side of the world, and decidedly NOT an environmental menace.

Over here in the Atlantic, not so much.

Scientists with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, among other entities studying the issue, have made lionfish Priority One, in the battle against invasive species. A rapid response plan is being crafted, to deal with them in our waters.

Avid divers, who know the reefs off Florida and the Bahamas, tell the story: A few years ago, they were somewhat awed to suddenly see the gorgeous specimen show up outside the Pacific. A fluke, they thought... maybe someone had released one from an aquarium, once they realized it would devour all the other pet fish in short order. Irresponsible to release them, but no real harm done-- they thought.

But since around 2000, those divers, fishermen, and scientists have rapidly had their amazement turn to dismay. On some reefs where they would see one or two lionfish, they began seeing dozens. In the Bahamas, they're now calling it an infestation.

Turns out, these lovely lions of the sea take no prisoners. Eat everything in sight. Multiply like there's no tomorrow. And grow. And spread. And spread.

The Atlantic has been very good to them. Lots of food, and no known predators. In just a few years time, the lionfish has made its merry way all the way up the East Coast to Massachusetts. It is the first time a Pacific marine fish has moved on into the Atlantic and thrived.

This is what happens when species invade.

We've seen it happen with pythons in the Everglades, or the snakehead fish in American rivers. Even invasive plants have caused trouble on our shores.

But many researchers told us they've never seen anything quite like this. How quickly and efficiently this one type of fish has been able to spread, and gain a foothold in delicate reef ecosystems. They're worried about the potential effect on native fish species and the ocean food chain.

One study that's to be published soon shows that ONE of these lionfish can devour around 80 percent of all new fish larvae on a section of reef in matter of a few weeks.

As NOAA biologist Paula Whitfield told us, " The densities of lionfish in North Carolina have increased over 300 percent since we started doing surveys, and that was in 2004. They have almost every attribute that could be valuable to survival."

It's too early to know what impact the lions are having, but anecdotally you hear it-- from fishermen and divers who say that where they see more lionfish, they see fewer of certain other species on a reef.

NOAA and other groups are working together to come up with a plan that will likely entail some localized eradication efforts. Bermuda has already started one, and the Bahamas has alerted fishermen to the problem. It is possible such efforts could help, as they've had success with other invasive species this way. It's just that when you see so many, in such a short amount of time, it's daunting.

"Cockroaches of the sea" is how one scientist glumly referred to these magnificent creatures. Yes, all depends on your perspective.

Sprung from their aquariums, these fish they must have thought they'd found paradise along the Gulf Stream.

One more reason why the House Natural Resources Subcommittee on Fisheries, Wildlife and Oceans is now reviewing draft legislation that would set up a screening process for bringing non-native animals into this country.

Lionfish are still legal to buy and keep-- and feed-- at home. Many people we talked to in researching this story, feel that ought to change.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Wikipedia has an article on the invasive lionfish, but the best article can be found, written 9-8-06, at the New York Times website. I think we should harvest this fish for biodeisel, along with any other invasive species.  Why?  For example, our lakes in Minnesota have numerous species (mostly plant, some animal) that have invaded our 10,000+ lakes and cost millions of dollars in damage and more cost trying to rid our waters of these invasive, non-native pests.  All states have invasive species causing problems.   They are a great fuel source because they are here and we need to get them under control.  What better way than to use them as biofuel?  Go to the MyGyan Process (mcgyan.com)website to see why. Also, sartec.com.
Cockroaches feed off of: what ever, ever each other. Lion fish do not feed in that manner. They do not eat corals, nor lobsters (maybe baby ones). They eat shrimp, and small fish. They are a predator at the top of the food chain. The way they were brutally massacred is barbaric. They could be collected and resold for approx. $100 - $200 ea. Why can't they be collected and resold for the aquarium trade or to produce and anti-venom? Use the money to purchase more boats or hire more crews to collect even more. It was appalling to witness the involvement of the "National Aquarium" killing these creatures.
I have just finished a dive trip in North Carolina. I have been doing this trip the same last week in June for about three years. We have seen firsthand the lionfish's path. Some are the size of basketballs. We see that the smaller fish are now gone and that the lionfish is just to much for the area. We will need to do something soon, are there will not be the sealife that we have seen.
I've spent time in the Bahamas (Eleuthera) since I was a child and some friends have found a way to remove the poisonous parts and eat the Lion Fish which as no preditors in the Atlantic.  Maurice White is starting a program to educate locals about the Lion Fish and teach them how to eat the fish that "tastes like chicken."  See a video on how to catch and eat them and informatin about educating local Bahamian's about the Lion fish.  http://web.mac.com/mojokingdom/iWeb/Site%2040/Lionfish%20Hunter.html
Some are stating to collect the fish and then sale them as pets. The issue with that is this is how the problem started in the first place.  Owners letting them go in the Ocean because they ate the other fish in the tank. We need divers to eliminate as many of these trouble causing fish as possible.  
Lionfish are a very serious invasive species and as such will significantly alter, if not destroy, the Atlantic reef ecosystem, as well as impact the fisheries and diving industries. They eat juvenile fish of commercial species, as well as the local reef fish of the coral reefs. This is the effect of man's (possibly) unintended, but foolish actions.
My graduate student, Mark Albins, and I are the authors of the cited new study (2008 Marine Ecology Progress Series) showing that a single lionfish can reduce the input of new fish to a small coral patch reef in the Bahamas by 80% in just 5 weeks.  As we continue our studies, it is becoming clear that the spread and intensity of this invasion is both unprecedented and staggering.
ridiculous story
I googled "Lionfish recipe" and found a youtube helpful solution. www.youtube.com/watch?v=hR-0zXnYMuc    
Two years ago while at our place on Eleuthera, Bahama, I first saw a Lionfish. In May, in the same area, I saw at least 2 dozen. I came home and searched the internet for help on a solution...this could be it!
I saw one a few years ago in the waters off  the island of Jt.John in the Caribbean.  I told the guy at the dive desk, and he did not dispute that I had in fact seen one.  He said a few other people had reported seeing them, too.  
To Save the Sea: I understand your sentiment - no one (well, ALMOST no one) enjoys watching creatures killed for doing what comes naturally to them.  Unfortunately, it would take only a tiny fraction of the individuals already out there to flood the aquarium market and drive costs to nil.  Most divers and fishermen don't have the equipment or time required to transport the fish live anyway, which, btw, accounts for a good portion of the cost at your local aquarium anyway, making it less attractive an option than it might appear to you.

One possible avenue to encourage their removal would be to subsidize sale of the fish (dead and frozen) to asian markets where, apparently, they're eaten, and to also try to develop a market domestically.  Then the gov't could fund a "bounty" with the proceeds to encourage their removal by those encountering them, w/o the need for any special equipment or training (other than a freezer).  Perhaps eventually a self-sustaining market would evolve.  

Unfortunately, even this would only serve to keep their #s down.  We're quite likely stuck w/ them for good now.
The waters off the USA and Carribean islands have no predators capable of defeating the lionfish. If there were such a predator, the lionfish would not have proliferated into such a huge problem in such a short time. One person called this a "ridiculous story". We are looking at an environmental melt down. How can this be riduculous? Capturing and selling them won't work - there are thousands. Capture and kill!!! Hack and slash!!!Eradicate by any means neccessary to save our waters!!!. Red Sea, Coral Sea, Tropical Pacific - fine that's were they belong -- NOT THE ATLANTIC.
that is amazing
If you need an aquarium to house all of those lion fish go to acrylicaquariums.com They can build a tank to hold them.  
can we make them eat one another:) and do they have any natural predators we could introduce?

I would like to speak for "Conscientious Aquarists" (borrowed the phrase from Bob Fenner at wetwebmedia) everywhere.  I know there are some out there that are releasing these fish, but those are the stupid and irresponsible ones.  Please, please, don't blame the aquarium trade itself, and please don't hold all of us responsible.  Many of us research before buying, care for our animals responsibly, and understand the impact releasing fish can have.  It's important to remember that, like everything, the folks who don't do the right thing are the ones who ruin it for everyone.  That being said, this is a horrible situation that could have been avoided had people done what is right, fair, and humane, rather than what was easy.  Thanks for listening to the crazy fish tank girl.
I would say the animal the lionfish most resembles is us... human beings. Think about it!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

RECENT STORIES FROM NIGHTLY NEWS

  • Nightly News section front

CONNECT WITH US

About the broadcast | Biographies

RSS is an easy way to get the news you want as it is updated even if you are not on MSNBC.com. More information about MSNBC.com's RSS feeds.

Subscribe to feed

Podcasting brings you audio and video from each weekday broadcast on your iPod or other portable MP3 player anytime, anywhere. More information about MSNBC.com's podcasts.

Subscribe to podcast

Sign-up for our daily e-mail newsletter. It offers a preview of the stories and special reports featured on each weekday broadcast.


Syndicate This Site

Add The Daily Nightly to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google