ABOUT THIS BLOG

The Daily Nightly began on May 31, 2005. As Brian wrote in his first post it aims to provide a narrative of the broadcast day and a window into the editorial process at NBC Nightly News. Brian weighs in every weekday and NBC News correspondents and producers post regularly.

Brian Williams became the seventh anchor and managing editor in the history of NBC Nightly News on December 2, 2004. Read his full biography.



Plastic bottles – are they safe?

Posted: Thursday, April 17, 2008 1:23 PM by Victor Limjoco

By Robert Bazell, NBC News chief science correspondent

 

For the past few days we have been covering an issue that is generating a lot of concern. Certain types of plastic containers can leech a chemical called bisphenol A (BPA). The chemical can mimic the female hormone estrogen. Given to animals at high doses it can cause all sorts of health problems ranging from infertility and obesity to several types of cancer.

There is no question that Americans are exposed to the chemical. A study by the CDC estimated that 92.6 percent of Americans age 6 and above had measurable BPA in their bodies.

The chemical industry has maintained for years that the high dose animal experiments do not show any human effects and the FDA, which would regulate the chemicals, has said there is no danger. Many scientists have continued to look for possible danger in both animal and human studies.

On Tuesday, the National Toxicology Program, a division of the National Institutes of Health issued an alarm The agency said there was a possibility BPA could be causing brain problems in fetuses and children and prostate and breast problems in adults.

The actual quote from the draft report concluded “there is some concern for neural and behavioral effects in fetuses, infants, and children at current human exposures. The NTP also has some concern for bisphenol A exposure in these populations based on effects in the prostate gland, mammary gland, and an earlier age for puberty in females.”

The designation of “some” concern is equivalent to 3 on a danger scale of 1 to 5. You can see the report itself here. A few members of Congress have issued calls for the FDA to ban the plastics. So far the FDA has not responded.

If you want to avoid bottles with BPA look on the bottom for very tiny numbers enclosed in arrows that look like this. The number 7 indicates BPA. The numbers 3 and 6 indicates the presence of similar chemicals that some scientists and environmentalists believe could be cause for concern.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

What about the re-use of water bottles with number  1 on the bottom, which it seems all bottled water companies use. Is it considered safe to re-use these bottles since they arn't made with the same materials as 3, 6, and 7?
Should I stop using these bottles?
Is BPA only in plastic bottles, or is it present in other plastic products, i.e. Tupperware, Zip-Loc bags, etc.
Thanks
Aww shucks. I've been drinking my water from a nalgene bottle for years now. It's in and out of the freezer daily, which I hope doesn't contribute to the leeching of this chemical. If I grow boobs or get cancer in my bowels, I know whose tushy I'll be looking to kick!
As a mother of a 2 year old can you tell me where I can get sippy cups that have a rating of 1 or 2.

"If you want to avoid bottles with BPA look on the bottom for very tiny numbers enclosed in arrows that look like this. The number 7 indicates BPA. The numbers 3 and 6 indicates the presence of similar chemicals that some scientists and environmentalists believe could be cause for concern."

Now that would be some useful information for your viewers who are now frantic over the fact that their daughter has been drinking from a number 5 rated sippy cups for the pas 2 years. Your help and information would be greatly appreciated.

Wow! I just stopped drinking out of plastic bottles. I always thought water was good for me, but in this case it's bad. Well it's back to tap water for me. Thanks for  bringing us the news.
So should we only be wary of numbers 3,6, and 7. What is our alternative? I appreciate the warning, however, it seems worthless without a go to solution. My children bring bottled water to school everyday for lunch. Is there a safe plastic refillable water bottle or do I scout for ole tyme thermos bottles at yard sales??????
About time.  Makes you wonder if there aren't other effects.  What is wrong with glass? Worked for years.
What about bottles that have no triangle indicator? I drink Propel 16.9 ounce vitamin water constantly and these are not marked with the triangle shape and number. I know that no one can give out direct names of products without a risk of lawsuit, but I just need to know about bottles "like these".
Not every bottle is marked. I have been looking at bottles recently due to all of the coverage on plastics -- several water and juice bottles are not marked at all. Are product manufacturers required to release the information?? If so, how does one confirm the plastic type?
Can you give an example of a type of bottle (brand) so that I can see what to look for.
You say hard plastic and my thought goes to sippy cups for babies and young children, are these types of containers also a problem?
Another thing you might want to warn parents against is play sand for children. I have recently read that there are toxins in the dust from play sand you buy at home depot etc. Please do a story and provide more accurate information with alternatives to purchasing safe sand for children. What the hell is the FDA doing for us anyway?
So, if congress does not respond, how many potential health problems in young adults will justify a change? 1,2, 5 million?
important news report
I have Sam's Choice Purified Drinking Water (with flavor enhancing minerals). Basically recycled tap water I think....

The bottom of the bottle has a 7, but the number inside arrows is a 1... Under the one the letters PETE. On another section of the bottle is the 7, but its actually a 07.... does that make it a BPA bottle?  Where can I find out for sure?
What about the numbers 1-2-4-5? Are they safe? If not then why were they not mentioned in the article? I don't want to use those plastics if they are not safe. I can go to all glass if necessary.
thanks for the info.I went to my pantry and found several bottles had the number 7 for the BPA.I had purchased them at Target for $1 thinking it was a bargain over the Nalgene sold at the EMS store.Well I'm tossing them all out now.
It seems to me that we Boomers were on the right track back in the 60's--You can't trust "Authority".  Assurances from the "chemical industry" do nothing to inspire confidence in me given their track record.  If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck....
Before we go totally overboard with this, someone ask the question. What amount of exposure is necessary for a possibility BPA exposure to cause brain damage. I remember a few years ago the scare with cranberries causing cancer. Results was way out of line then.
Recently I was shopping for baby food fruits and looked at the plastic bottle class and I was surprized to find they were class 7. I did not buy and wonder about the infants getting this food.
This is the article on nbc w/Brian Williams, that I was talking about...I checked the bottom of my water gallons from Walmart(distilled) has a 1.  My single water bottle (Aquafina) has a 2....so that's good. On this article you can click on the blue line that says: Looks Like This
I drink about one gallon bottle a day and have been doing so for 6yrs. should I be concerned? I have breast concerned? I have not been feeling well.
So what kind of bottle can I safely use with my 4 monthold baby daughter?  Glass only?  This is scary?
Why is no mention being made of the fact that this is also in the plastic linings in 85% of the cans used to store food and also in the material used to seal the teeth of children?
Mothers beware- Gerber uses this plastic. I found the 7 on the bottom of the organic individual juices and the organic baby food. I would assume they use the same plastics for all of their products.
So what kind of plastic bottles are safe?
Is anything safe anymore? I'm a nursing mother and I also have a 3 year old and I've alreay stopped buying items made in China; including toys, drinking and eating utensils, and even bottles. Not to mention Organic foods. Now am I suppose start looking under every orange juice and milk jug, or is Organic Milk and Organic Orange juice in glass containers going to be a new item on my grocery list. Please give me some relief from all this new information. Is there a website about BPA free products?
I have checked our bottles and the like and have thrown away the ones in question. However, I have noticed that some do not have a number on them. I was at the store the day I heard this story and checked bottles there, some did not have a number. I even peeled off the UPC code to check under it and still no number. At this point I would like congress to address this issue.
Hello,
Interesting questions above. Will you do a follow-up article to answer some of those questions. i.e. What is an alternative? Can the others besides 3, 6 & 7, be washed to be re-used? How do you find the numbers on those with-out numbers? What about all the other foods coming in plastic (#1 on them mostly) such as catsup (acidic), jelly, peanut butter, etc?
Thanks!

Dear NBC - and Mr. Bazell in particular... please KEEP ON THIS STORY.  Without NBC's persistent investigation of this subject, this story could easily be "swept under the rug".  Thank you for helping the public be aware of this possible problem.
Sure glad I've only used Born Free bottles and sippy cups for my little one!  And everyone thought I was being paranoid!
Does it matter where the plastic bottle are manufacured? Does the FDA approve certain bottles over another? I have one that reades PC and a "1" in the triangle. What does mean? The letters do not match those indicated in the report.
Thanks!
I see these comments with some of the same questions me and my family have, but, no examples.  Should I finish the V8 or have a 7up?
After hearing about the #7 on bottles I began to check all my plastic and was very surprised to find that the baby food plastic containers are #7. This includes Gerber and the Walmart brand, and not sure how many others. I have switched to jarred food now, but am concerned and wonder how companies can produce baby products using this dangerous material.
I just watched this report. I work for a outdoor retail company. First, Mr Bazell, the plastics companies are doing something about it. The new bottles we have been receiving are now
BPA free. They are using a polyester plastic that is completely different and BPA free.
Get your facts together before you come out and say " nothing is being done, about it" because the retail companies and the manufacturers are doing something about it. Oh and try mentioning that there are aluminum and stainless steel bottles out on the market. These can be used in place of the plastic. If any of you folks ever have a question ask your retail sales specialist and get the lowdown.
I agree with Maureen- Brian spent a very few seconds on this subject which affects a great majority of us and then twice the time on the middle east embassy...
like we'll all be there...  come on- get with reality of the "common folk".
I can't believe the health and well being of the consumer is totally ignored for GREED of the almighty dollar. Products are marketed with no conscience or accountability. I think this is one of many hazardous products sold and this must be stopped.
Bad Brian! Not all Nalgene bottles are BPA. For you worriers: numbers on the bottom of a bottle that are NOT wrapped with the recycling-arrows-triangle are usually mold or model numbers from the manufacturing process. Molded soft plastic ware, such Tupperware, is not BPA-based; BPA is used in the hard-shiny plastic, especially seen in the neon-bright colors. There is more of a concern if the container is heated and not just used to store food. That's why the baby bottle point is being hyped.

Please don't overreact, this story actually isn't news. It's been around for at least 10 years.
Thank you for bringing awareness to this issue of the dangers of certain plastics.The FDA needs to get off their butts and start protecting people instead of approving another drug with all the potential deadly side effects and overdoses that happen each year.
My son was born premature, and I have gone to extreme measures to safeguard his health for the past twenty-two months. After watching the BPA broadcast tonight, my husband and I found a "7" on the bottom of Gerber baby food containers, convenient single serving containers of Dole vegetables and fruits, and ketchup!!  All this time, I thought I was doing the right thing by serving him organic baby food, and the whole time, I was putting his health at risk because Gerber saved money by using plastic containers that leak BPA!  If you can't trust Gerber, who can you trust?  In all of these broadcasts warning us of the dangers of BPA, I am sure there was a simulcast somewhere discussing the medical epidemic of autism and/or ADHD. How hard can it be to figure out that there is probably a correlation here?  No more 7's at our house.  
My son was born premature, and I have gone to extreme measures to safeguard his health for the past twenty-two months. After watching the BPA broadcast tonight, my husband and I found a "7" on the bottom of Gerber baby food containers, convenient single serving containers of Dole vegetables and fruits, and ketchup!!  All this time, I thought I was doing the right thing by serving him organic baby food, and the whole time, I was putting his health at risk because Gerber saved money by using plastic containers that leak BPA!  If you can't trust Gerber, who can you trust?  In all of these broadcasts warning us of the dangers of BPA, I am sure there was a simulcast somewhere discussing the medical epidemic of autism and/or ADHD. How hard can it be to figure out that there is probably a correlation here?
While recycling (BPA or non-BPA) is commendable, I was surpised that none of the bottled products from Coca Cola have ANY recycling number (1-7) on them while bearing a label "Please Recycle". Is there BPA in every Coke product?  Even my soap dispenser has a number.  

Maybe the FDA considers it important enough to identify plastics on soap dispensers, but not on the containers that Americans consume every day.

BTW Coke's consumer line number is 800-438-2653.

Seems everytime we open a newspaper, turn on the TV or flip on the radio we hear about toxins in our environment.  I went looking for an alternative and found a neat wellness company that manufactures safely.  What a relief for this Mom of three.  How can I get in touch with others on your site to share this?
Ok, I understand that glass baby bottles are  the safest.  What about the plastic ring that holds the silicone nipple onto the glass bottle.  Is the plastic screw on ring safe and  if not where can we purchase a safe alternative?  Also where can we purchase a safe alternative to plastic water bottles, so that we can carry water with us?
 
Why not go green by not using plastic bottles & switch back to glass. Glass bottles are cleaner & safer & don't have that plastic smell or have BPA in them. Next time you go into the store. I challenge you to look at the bottom of the next gallon container of AriZona Green Tea with Ginsing & Honey. What number do you see? (#7 & #5)   I won't be drinking the balance of my tea in the PBA plastic bottle. We'll be making own tea. Until the company's decides to make a change. Thanks Brian & Robert Bazell at NBC for informing the public.
In the car, we have been using glass Snapple bottles for water, and wash the bottles between uses.  When the metal cap starts to show rust, we replace it with another Snapple bottle and cap.
A note to the parent looking at the plastic baby food containers, I personally emailed Gerber foods about that and they told me their containers are lined. If you heat them, it separates. As for other brands, I don't know. But I totally agree! We're using this "garbage" to feed our children - OUR FUTURE. We are their parents and we're supposed to protect them but instead we're potentially poisoning them? What gives? Why can't all the plastic be made out of 1 or 2 since they are recyclable and better for the planet too?
Gerber's (plastic, snap on lid) baby food containers have a number 7 with the word OTHER under it. What does OTHER mean. Does it still contain BPA? I'm going back to glass baby food jars. Glass is safe, Isn't it?
Plastics with the number 7 is so widely used, it is used for yogurt, water, meat, just about everything we use.  What are we suppose to do?  I have a lot of cancer in my family history; therefore I am doing everything that I can to lower my risk.  This news is not optimistic or helpful.  Is there any advice?
Yup, just looked at my pink Breast Cancer Awareness  water bottle that I use every time I work out. (Of course, one of the reasons I work out is to lower my risks of getting breast cancer.) What do I find  on the bottem of my pink bottle but a 7 enclosed in arrows.  Ahhhh, the irony...


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

RECENT STORIES FROM NIGHTLY NEWS

  • Nightly News section front

CONNECT WITH US

About the broadcast | Biographies

RSS is an easy way to get the news you want as it is updated even if you are not on MSNBC.com. More information about MSNBC.com's RSS feeds.

Subscribe to feed

Podcasting brings you audio and video from each weekday broadcast on your iPod or other portable MP3 player anytime, anywhere. More information about MSNBC.com's podcasts.

Subscribe to podcast

Sign-up for our daily e-mail newsletter. It offers a preview of the stories and special reports featured on each weekday broadcast.


Syndicate This Site

Add The Daily Nightly to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google