ABOUT THIS BLOG

The Daily Nightly began on May 31, 2005. As Brian wrote in his first post it aims to provide a narrative of the broadcast day and a window into the editorial process at NBC Nightly News. Brian weighs in every weekday and NBC News correspondents and producers post regularly.

Brian Williams became the seventh anchor and managing editor in the history of NBC Nightly News on December 2, 2004. Read his full biography.



About last night...

Posted: Friday, January 25, 2008 5:25 PM by Sam Singal

By Brian Williams, Anchor and managing editor

Apparently while I was in the air en route home from Florida there was some traffic on the Internet about last night's grassy knoll "whispered moment" right after this question from Tim Russert to Mitt Romney during the debate: "Will you do for Social Security what Ronald Reagan did in 1983?" With the benefit of an earpiece on stage, I distinctly heard what some viewers apparently heard. Someone said in a whisper, but audibly:

"He raised taxes..."

I remember looking around the stage with a start - scanning the faces of the candidates, trying to figure out who had just said that. Apparently, others heard it, too. We're actually polling all of our folks (those who were anywhere near an open mike) and watching all of our iso tapes (where we record camera angles that isolate individual candidates) to see who the whispering bandit is. Its not as if anyone committed any offense - in fact, whoever it was was both fast on the draw and correct about where Tim was going with his question. It was just an oddly disjointed, not-immediately-identifiable voice, thus the mystery.

Back in New York, I'm here to tell you today's Continental Airlines flight 700 from Ft. Lauderdale to Newark was one of the worst I've ever been on. This time it wasn't the airline's fault. It was the people on the plane: nasty kids, even worse parents... a situation made that much more nightmarish by the continuing horror of the discovery I made boarding our flight to Miami two nights ago: My iPod was in its charger - in my office - and not in my briefcase. The prospect of traveling without it terrifies me, and during the opening 30 minutes of today's flight I would have done anything to have had just ONE of my 2,500 songs. I've never been so happy to see my home state come into view, as we circled over Soprano-land on final approach over the urban jungle of northern Jersey prior to landing.

I was driving through Las Vegas ten days ago with producer Subrata De (on our way to a redeye to New York, I recall - it all tends to run together) when I motioned toward a cluster of existing high-rise hotels, adjacent to some new construction, the Monte Carlo hotel among them. I mentioned the struggle of the Las Vegas Fire Department to stay ahead of the construction boom (there are 40,000 new hotel rooms currently under construction) and made some sort of vague, dark prediction akin to "one of these days, one of these is gonna go up..." And by the time we landed this afternoon and arrived in the newsroom, every television was showing live pictures of the fire at the Monte Carlo. It took a long while to get water on that fire today, and I imagine there will be a long investigation into how it happened and how quickly it spread. Note the jet-black smoke that came from the initial incursion of the fire into those hotel rooms: That's the carpeting, wall coverings, fabrics, furniture, electronics - all the synthetic materials and surfaces and fabrications that make up today's commercial construction. I don't envy the Battalion Chief who was the first to roll up on the scene of that one today. Considering how it might have ended, a lot of people have a lot of blessings to count today in Las Vegas.

Friday night's broadcast covers the Vegas fire, the political campaign (including the the whispering mystery if we managed to solve it soon enough for airtime), the Gaza situation, the war in Iraq - capped off by our Friday night feature on those who are Making a Difference. Saturday night, we'll be back here at work to cover the South Carolina results. Then on Monday, it's off to Washington for the president's State of the Union speech. We sure hope you can join us.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Hi Brian -

Once a volunteer fireman, always a volunteer fireman.  I am the widow of one, and one of his rules was - there will never be candles in this house.

There were many of those rules, all learned on the unexpected visits to unexpected fires.

Poor Brian, that you forgot your iPod.

I hope the Presidential candidates of the Republican Party will not run out of money, as seen on the website: http://www.opensecrets.org/pres08/index.asp

Also I hope, after the polls in South Carolina, Mike Gravel will drop out.

Stay safe travelling Brian.
Bad parents and bad kids.  Need to be disciplined.
Willard the Rat was in Mitt Romney's inside coat pocket and his whisper was just a little too loud.  Romney goes around with his little rat friend with him.  Somewhat akin to what Karl Rove did for George W. Bush.  Except that Willard also has a weather vane with him.
Clark County Fire Department did an amazing job battling a very fast moving fire.  Within a quick amount of time the blaze had spread throughout the top of the Monte Carlo.  However, within a little over an hour that fire was contained and later extinquished.  Considering 3000 people are able to stay at the Monte Carlo and no one was hurt is amazing.  Clark County and the City of Las Vegas should be commended for averting a disaster by being prepared.
The children are not nasty.  Pretty lame to call children nasty.  If they were not being controlled by their parents, then it's the parents fault.  
Political Mud-slinging is at an all time high. Mr. "I did not have sex with that woman!" seems to be finger pointing; Mr. "Mitt" tells us who is not like "Ronald Reagan"; Everybody asks "Who is the most black or latino candidate?"; I am sick of it all - Come on November 5th!!!!!
Mr. Williams, I would like you more so to address the Mormon question you asked Mitt Romney last night ("44% of respondents to a recent survey think a Mormon president would have a difficult time unifying the country").  As Article VI Blog and Hugh Hewitt have uncovered in the following article: (http://www.article6blog.com/2008/01/25/brian-williams-religion-question-to-romney-borderline-mendacity/), the survey you cited never made mention of the word Mormon, only about Mitt Romney.  The same survey scored Mike Huckabee with 43% and Giuliani with 46% on the same question.  Why did you not ask them:  why do 43% and 46% of Americans think a Baptist or a Catholic, respectively, cannot unify
the country?  Did you have an agenda against Mormons last night?  I'm sure this is not the case.  Please clarify your seemingly bigotted question.
If it's an infant in arms who is screaming, I feel sorry for the parents as well, because as we all know sometimes it just happens.  However, I do blame parents who do not control their older children.  They seem to expect all of us to think their obnoxious children are cute.  I once sat near a woman with FOUR children and she did NOTHING.  She even expected the flight attendant to handle it when one of the kids threw up.  Thank heavens the flight attendant did not.
Nasty children = Nasty parents, and vice verse...
You should have been fair in the Florida debates last night, and you know you were not.  Both Republican debates (SC-Fox & FL-MSNBC) were designed to get votes for Romney/McCain.  Obviously money is more important to you and MSNBC than integrity.  Only one commentator told the truth about the FL debate, but that didn't happen until 12:30 a.m. Joining your hatred of Huckabee, Jeff Greenfield (CNN) stated this morning that "only the uneducated middle class would vote for Huckabee."  The American people should be deciding who gets the nomination, not the networks and the GOP/Democratic parties big shots.    
Time will tell but it looked like no actual hotel rooms caught on fire. It looked more like the facade of the building, which is probably made out of some fiberglass or plastic foam had caught on fire. It then burned and driped down the building catching more of it on fire. Looks like there should be a code to make that stuff fire resistant.
ABOUT LAST NIGHT... It was so balant again last nite, at your so called "debates" (and ALL the major news do this)that you have a major bias against Dr. Ron Paul. Heres the facts from last night that you can't deny: Air/face time were as follows: Romney = 23 mins/14 questions, McCain = 21 mins/13 questions, Guiluani = 19 mins/13 questions, Huckabee = 15 mins/12 questions, Paul = 6 mins/3 questions!! Now how is this a fair debate? Brian Williams? You have deliberately chosen to shut out the campaign of Ron Paul. Ron Paul got to speak for less than 6 minutes, and in that time, put everyone to shame, especially McCain. I'm sure that the FCC is watching all this unfold during this election year. And the American people are seeing what the major media giants are really made up of.
right. there are plenty of nasty ass children out there.
It was the Dog Whisperer "Cesar Millan", and he didn't say "He raised taxes..." he said "Romney waxes."  



Why do you wear contacts??  At one of the debates I saw you in glasses - and you look better.  Contacts make you squint your eyes; make your brows crooked; and furrow your brow.  WHY are you wearing them???
All candidates should be asked the same questions, but not by the media, as the media can't get anything right.  They should be asked by those of the current GOP.
Why did you so blatantly misrepresent the survey last night, citing "Mormon", when it was not mentioned? How about an explanation. You empty suits are an anachronism-news anchor-give me a break!  You are useless, clueless and dead as the dinosaurs.
Brian-If it was not for Fox America would have ABC,CBS,NBC,CNN, You, Wolf, Katie, Jack, Wolf's pal, Matthews ect.all of which are openly for the Democratic party. Shame that the news is bias instead of being reported like baseball scores.
Did you check the tapes for a square box between the shoulder blades similar to what Bush wore during one of his debates?  Could it be someone's ear plug fell out?
Hi Brian,

Just curious as to where you obtained those 2,500 songs on your iPod. Did you pay 99 cents each and download them? $2,500 is a lot of money for music, most people can't afford that, maybe you can. Maybe you ripped some from CDs that you purchased. Some recent flak by the RIAA that that's illegal. They have since changed their tune. Did you borrow some CDs from friends or co-workers? Now, the RIAA still maintains that is illegal. Like I said, just curious.
You know, there really are bigger "horrors" in life than having to read the airline's magazine because you forgot your iPod.
Hi Brian!
I think that you (the media) should keep talking about the "whispered moment" of last nights debate because I feel like candidate Romney thinks he's  smarter than us and that's not the truth.
Teach him a lesson beacuse he can't cheat on us!
Brian, I think you do a great job braodcasting the news and mediating debates.  You appear to be a very level headed person who has an abundance of integrity. I watch the NBC Nightly News whenever I can.
With all the traveling you do, why don't you get a private jet?

I personally know some nasty children. It happens. Unfortunately, nasty parents are not too far away.
Brian: You are smart enough to know your credibility is on the line here as relates to the "Mormon president" question at last night's debate.  Apparently, the poll carries NO mention of the "Mormon president".  Fess up, Brian. I'd like to think there's one guy on network TV whose integrity I can admire.  You're on the bubble, bud.
I would have to agree with Jon. I was curious what he meant by the Nasty Kids comment. Does that mean older kids being a pain, or small children who deserve to travel and see family, other parts of the world, etc. and who are not as emotionally stable as we are, and sometimes travel very well, considering, but sometimes do need to vent, or are nervous, or their ears hurt or whatever. We have three awesome kids, and we travel with them quite a bit. Most of the time they are silent, polite travelers. Once in a while the youngest makes some noise. Should we just stay at home so not to potentially annoy some traveler?
This is a pretty accurate account of the bias that exist in MSM (MSNBC, CNN, Faux News, etc)

Total Air/Face Times From MSNBC Debate/Jan 24
Romney: 21:11, during 13 times
McCain: 16:00, during 13 times
Giuliani: 13:50, during 11 times
Huckabee: 12:11, during nine times
Paul: 6:31, during six times

And Brian W. who cares about McCains 120 yr old mothers views on anything, my God man!
Good Evening Mr.Williams, After reading about your experience on the flight I am so very sorry. Sometimes children just don't mind their parents or the parents do nothing to stop them from behaving badly. I really am sorry you had to deal with all that noise and the fact you forgot your I-Pod. Try desperately to remember it next time you are going to fly on board a plane and you will possibly have a more peaceful flight. Those 2,500 songs on your I-Pod will sound like heaven the next time you fly. I just want to say too that you and Mr.Russert did a great job moderating the Republican Debate last evening. All the candidates seemed to be civil towards eachother for an evening. Now on to the broadcast. As I always say it it wonderful to see Richard on the broadcast! Richard's report concerning the future of the US troops role in Iraq  and the possibilty it will come to an agreement by July in the Iraqi Parliament was very informative as always. The sermon being spoken that was anti-American could stem from the people wanting the US troops to leave because they feel that the troops have been there too long in Iraq. The listing of objectives in Richard's report seems as if they don't want us there, but they are afraid of the consequences if we leave. There has to come a point where the Iraqi forces must stand on there own and become more self-sufficient. Our brave US troops cannot be there indefinitely in the country. Hopefully, the region will become a more peaceful one especially for the children of the country like the ones playing on the playground Richard was walking in and speaking with the father. One prays the country will not collapse after our troops leave. Peace has to be the conclusion. All one can do is wait. Another great report by Richard!! Stay safe as always Richard!! On another note about the Middle East it appears tensions over the border with Egypt and Gaza was high. Hopefully, again there can be a peaceful resolution over that situation. Anyway, much news about politics this week and especially this weekend with the South Carolina Primary. I will look forward to your broadcast this Saturday evening. I'm sure it will be eventful. In the meantime try to relax this evening after a very busy week. Thank you for the broadcast Mr.Williams. Stay Safe always Richard!!! Peace to all!
Three points: First, why would any of the other candidates give Romney a hint?  This should be investigated.  Second: terrible bias against Huckabee in debate time.  He has done far more to justify his candidacy than Giuliani. Third: If anyone out there agrees it was unfair, you can join in Huckabee's online fundraiser, going on right now.

"We're actually polling all of our folks"

"Its not as if anyone committed any offense"

So, let me get this straight. You currently have no idea who the whisperer was, but you've already decided there was no offenses committed? Why aren't we waiting for all (in fact, any) of the information on this to come into the light before assuming whether or not there is funny business involved? Come on, Brian... you are smarter than this.
Dear Mr. Williams, Iam so diappointed, at the false and misleading question you asked Mitt Romney last night, ("44% of respondents to a recent survey think a Mormon president would have a difficult time unifying the country").  As Article VI Blog and Hugh Hewitt have uncovered in the following article: (http://www.article6blog.com/2008/01/25/brian-williams-religion-question-to-romney-borderline-mendacity/), the survey you cited never made mention of the word Mormon, only about Mitt Romney.  The same survey scored Mike Huckabee with 43% and Giuliani with 46% on the same question.  Why didn't you ask them:  why do 43% and 46% of Americans think a Baptist or a Catholic, respectively, cannot unify
the country?  Did you have a predjudice against his religious  beliefs or are you just intellectually dishonest.  You hold a seat of power, so I suggest you use it wisely.  I'm a christian so are all my  friends and family here in California and we have no problem, with his choice of religion.  Nor should it be mentioned considering our constitution.  Shame on you.
Mr. Williams, why is the mainstream media determined to tout John McCain when he is not the front runner in the delegate count so far for the Republican Nomination.  It is obvious the media has a bias towards this candidate as his face is plastered all over NBC's website and touted in every interview.  Kindly stick to the facts and if you can't be unbaised, at least admit it so that no one will be duped by your obvious liberal agenda. Oh, and why the obvious dig at Mitt Romney's religion?  Bigotry still alive and well in America?
Will NBC or MSNBC actually cover what ABCNews is reporting about Obama and Rezko's campaign contributions?  

http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/story?id=4192358&page=1

Months after reporters started asking Sen. Barack Obama to account for contributions raised by longtime friend and donor Antoin "Tony" Rezko, questions remain about the full extent of the accused Illinois political fixer's role as a patron of Obama's political career.

"We have returned any money that we know was associated to Mr. Rezko," Obama told Diane Sawyer on Wednesday morning during an appearance on "Good Morning America." "That is something that if there's additional information we don't know about, we'd be happy to return the money."

The Obama campaign says it has given away more than $85,000 in Rezko-linked contributions since Rezko was indicted on federal fraud and extortion charges in the fall of 2006.

An ABCNews.com review, however, has identified an additional $100,000 in contributions made to Obama from Rezko's associates that have not been returned, including $19,500 in contributions from Rezko's wife and employees of Rezko's business enterprises. The ABCNews.com review includes individuals who have been linked to Rezko in news reports, court documents and public records.

Other news organizations have reviewed Obama's campaign finance records and have also found Rezko-linked contributions that are more than double what the campaign has publicly acknowledged. The Chicago Sun-Times, which published its review last June, found that "Obama has collected at least $168,308 from Rezko and his circle," and earlier this week the Los Angeles Times reported that it had found that Rezko and his associates had given "Obama more than $200,000 in donations since 1995."



So, what tunes do you have on your ipod?  RU a rock-n-roll kinda guy or more jazzy?  Inquiring minds want to know:-)   I think we are so lucky that the hotel fire wasn't a lot worse than it was!  Most of the building was saved, thank goodness for Fire Sprinkler Systems,they Save Lives! and I think you look great in contacts, btw
Mr. Williams, I agree with Chris Thompson from Syracuse, NY.  At this point of the primary process, is it possible for the media to move past the Mormon issue?  I believe that the US Government has become the largest bankrupt business in the world and needs someone with a business mentality to address the financial truth.  Was this another attempt by the liberal leaning media to thwart our best candidate by bringing up the controversial "Mormon" issue again?  You need to explain your, or whomevers, reasoning on the fictious question.  Thnk you.
The "He Raised Taxes" Whisper During MSNBC Florida Debate
http://ronpaul.meetup.com/281/messages/boards/view/viewthread?thread=4115310

Romney admits he doesnt care about voters! lol @ Romney
http://ronpaul.meetup.com/281/messages/boards/view/viewthread?thread=4117091

Mike Huckabee gets Gored! . . .in Arkansas (HOME STATE) Straw Poll!
http://ronpaul.meetup.com/281/messages/boards/view/viewthread?thread=4118114
What is wrong with the mainstream media? Obvious bias with regard to how much time a candidate gets. Ron Paul has "raised" more money, actually breaking records in the process, from individual Americans than any other candidate--yet is given only 6 minutes of time all night? Sometimes I wonder if we really do live in the land of the free....or the United States of Corporate America.
I've read through all of the comments and I'm amazed by the number of comments regarding the misbehaving children and other superfluous matters (contact lenses and i-Pods).80% of the responses are are idiotic and it makes me wonder who would spend their time to give their 2 cents....
Guilty as charged, I'm an idiot too. I hope your club has no membership fee.
Brian,

Word is that you deliberately mistorted the content of a poll question in last night's debate.  The question was directed at Romney and included his Mormonism.  True or false?
Keep rocking the news Brian!
After reviewing the tapes, NBC determined that an open mic picked up a whisper from the audience. It is unclear who it is that says it, but it was not said by any of the candidates, was not heard in the hall and, more importantly, not heard by the candidates.

http://firstread.msnbc.msn.com/archive/2008/01/25/609835.aspx
This was asked before, and you've chosen not to respond.  Your really need to.  This is outrageous and disgusting behavior.  Your "I'm a very reasonable guy" personna is sinking fast.  You are a religious bigot.

Mr. Williams, I would like you more so to address the Mormon question you asked Mitt Romney last night ("44% of respondents to a recent survey think a Mormon president would have a difficult time unifying the country").  As Article VI Blog and Hugh Hewitt have uncovered in the following article: (http://www.article6blog.com/2008/01/25/brian-williams-religion-question-to-romney-borderline-mendacity/), the survey you cited never made mention of the word Mormon, only about Mitt Romney.  The same survey scored Mike Huckabee with 43% and Giuliani with 46% on the same question.  Why did you not ask them:  why do 43% and 46% of Americans think a Baptist or a Catholic, respectively, cannot unify
the country?  Did you have an agenda against Mormons last night?  I'm sure this is not the case.  Please clarify your seemingly bigotted question.
Brian,

I agree with others who have sent comments about the "Mormon question."  How unprofessional.  Bigotry is alive and well here in America!
I was concerned with the aggresively negative questioning from your partners.  This was a debate, not Meet The Press, which allows a different approach.  

In my view, you did a good job.  Your parnters did not.
Scott, that little rat friend is Brian Williams. In Denver the local media only talks about McCain even though Romney has been ahead in Florida for three weeks straight. That's sanctuary city Denver...
Huckabee will be a tv evangelist in the very near future. He is getting alot of exposure for free. I can see him preaching to the choir if you know what I mean. He will be the next Jerry Falwell or Pat Robertson. Also he could be a leader in one of the white racist organizations that proudly fly the rebel flag. He could be more influential then David Duke. For sure Huckabee is about money. In my state of Arkansas he had his hand out more then maybe even Orval Faubus and that is saying alot. Huckabee kept the state of Arkansas ethics commission busy. He had more hidden funds and freebies then a Nazi war criminal.
Huckabee will be a tv evangelist in the very near future. He is getting alot of exposure for free. I can see him preaching to the choir if you know what I mean. He will be the next Jerry Falwell or Pat Robertson. Also he could be a leader in one of the white racist organizations that proudly fly the rebel flag. He could be more influential then David Duke. For sure Huckabee is about money. In my state of Arkansas he had his hand out more then maybe even Orval Faubus and that is saying alot. Huckabee kept the state of Arkansas ethics commission busy. He had more hidden funds and freebies then a Nazi war criminal.
Mr. Williams: I'm sure you're well aware you've been accused today of committing some pretty serious malfeasance in fabricating that number of Americans who allegedly couldn't vote for a mormon in your question to Gov Romney last night. Have you any intention of explaining where/how you pulled out a poll number from that WSJ poll which doesn't even exist? No such question was asked by the WSJ pollsters about mormonism at all.  Do you have any intention of explaining where you came up with thatbogus figure? Or can America just now assume you're a unapologetic religious hatemonger & begin to contact all your sponsors to inform them we'll begin to take our business elsewhere? I'm not a mormon, but I'm not about to help financially underwrite a newscast that continues to target this kind of ugly garbage against an entire group of innocent people, since your refusal  to even address your own apparent ethical misconduct in this sorry episode requires us to conclude that you have every intention of continuing to engage in it.
If the microphone that picked up the 'whisper' was that of Mr. Romney then it was likely the use of an 'Audio Spotlight'. It is a commercial device used to target a very specific area with sound, typically used for advertising.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

RECENT STORIES FROM NIGHTLY NEWS

  • Nightly News section front

CONNECT WITH US

About the broadcast | Biographies

RSS is an easy way to get the news you want as it is updated even if you are not on MSNBC.com. More information about MSNBC.com's RSS feeds.

Subscribe to feed

Podcasting brings you audio and video from each weekday broadcast on your iPod or other portable MP3 player anytime, anywhere. More information about MSNBC.com's podcasts.

Subscribe to podcast

Sign-up for our daily e-mail newsletter. It offers a preview of the stories and special reports featured on each weekday broadcast.


Syndicate This Site

Add The Daily Nightly to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google