ABOUT THIS BLOG

The Daily Nightly began on May 31, 2005. As Brian wrote in his first post it aims to provide a narrative of the broadcast day and a window into the editorial process at NBC Nightly News. Brian weighs in every weekday and NBC News correspondents and producers post regularly.

Brian Williams became the seventh anchor and managing editor in the history of NBC Nightly News on December 2, 2004. Read his full biography.



Greenland -- poster child for global warming

Posted: Monday, September 17, 2007 4:40 PM by Sam Go
Filed Under: ,

by Anne Thompson, chief environmental affairs correspondent

Tonight, we will take you to Greenland's vast and forbidding ice sheet. Some 300 miles wide and 1200 miles long, it is the poster child if you will, for global warming. Here you can see the melting first hand. (WATCH ANNE'S VIDEO BLOG FROM GREENLAND)

Spontaneous rivers and streams that occur in the annual summer thaw... but getting bigger and faster every year as the temperature rises.

We went to the ice sheet with Konrad Steffen, a climatologist from the University of Colorado at Boulder. He is a rock star in the world of global warming. At our hotel in Ilulissat, he would hold court in the lobby and dining room. The Hotel Hvide Falk (white falcon) is the choice for scientists and Steffen is the magnet. Young researchers literally sat at his knee to hear his insights about what's happening to the ice.

Steffen has been coming to Greenland for 18 years, longer than anyone else. The Danish Meterological Center in Denmark says the summer of 2007 was the second warmest since records started being kept in 1962.

This towering Swiss-born scientist is a charismatic loner... revelling in the solitude of the ice sheet.

Since 1990, his base has been Swiss Camp, a group of three tent buildings on a platform plus a sauna. He chose the spot because the melt and snowfall are the same so the ice never changes. But it did this year. He saw record melt there losing about 4 feet of snow and 3 feet of ice. The melting now threatens the buildings.

On our trip, we did not go to Swiss Camp but rather to a spot some 30 miles northeast of Ilulissat. There were not structures here and certainly no sauna, just ice as far as you could see. Steffen went to measure the moulins which are vertical caves. He believes the moulins send the meltwater down between the ice sheet and the bedrock. There he says it acts like a lubricant and moves the ice sheet... putting more ice into the ocean that will raise sea levels.

To interview Steffen and watch him work, we had to camp on the ice sheet. Now I have a confession to make: I never camped before this story. Producer Mario Garcia, photographer Bruce Bernstein and his son and soundman Curt all had plenty of experience but I was a rookie. As we planned our trip Mario told me he had good news and bad news for me: "The bad news Annie, is there is no Four Seasons. The good news is I bought you a Four Season tent." The tent and the whole experience was incredible. I would go back to the ice sheet in the proverbial New York minute. The only thing I can even imagine it compares to is being on the moon. There are no birds, no fish, no trees. Nothing. It is just you and the ice and it is spectacular. Yes, it gets very cold at night.... down to 14 degrees.... but the entire experience is worth a little shivering.

Not only did I camp, but I also cooked two meals on the ice sheet. That is two more meals than I cooked all summer in my New York apartment. Now Mario and Bruce, being manly men, didn't want to bring a stove. They said all we'd need to eat would be cheese and crackers. Curt and I on the other hand could see the advantages of hot meals, soups and drinks, especially if we got stuck on the ice sheet. That led to a camping contest of the Cheeseheads (apologies to Packer fans) versus the Pastaheads... Mario and Bruce versus Curt and me. The Pastaheads brought a little stove (more like the Bunsen burner I remember in chemistry class), cooked pasta, Ramen noodles and made instant espresso. But we could not have done it without the Cheeseheads help. Mario and Bruce figured out how to make the stove work, I cooked and Curt ate. Actually, we all ate and lived to tell about it. Maybe I'll try cooking at home.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Ann Thompson: I just saw your report on the melt down in Greenland. To be honest with you I'm tired of being blamed for the Global warming. I think it's time to do studies and reports on how the space shuttle is punching holes in our atmosphere and allowing uv rays to warm up this planet. Plus all the experimental nuclear blast the U.S. and other countries have done. Also how the military is dumping special punch (aluminum particles in their fuel) to control our weather and to cool off Planet Earth. This problem of Global Warming goes further than poor people trying to making a living with their cars and using their "hairspray." Your article was exceptional but depressing to us that can't control what the governments of the world want to do. Thank you for hearing me out.
I obviously liked NBC's segment on Greenland, but just as obviously I think it lacked a lot of substance.  To me, hearing how the Swiss scientist had to field calls about peoples beach houses was hardly worth the airtime.  Instead, maybe a little something more about how tens if not hundreds of millions of people living in coastal cities like New York would be effected and how even a three to six foot sea level rise there could entirely flood the subway system.  Miami would be 20 miles out at sea and after the ice is gone, the darker colored surface rock would absorb even more heat to create an even warmer planet.  Why also not show one of the very revieling maps of all of greenland that show the radar data of just how extensive the ice is melting.  The contrast between people worrying about their beach houses and what would really be cause for alarm shows just how much I think these segments are lacking (at least the few I have seen).  In your one report you made a sprawing single family home sound like the key just because it was made of recycled materials.  For that matter a hummer is ecologically friedly because it also is made of recycled metals (NOT). With a 20% drop in arctic sea ice over the last record low in 2005, I implor you to be more forthcoming with real warnings and more data.  
Dear Anne, I was really impressed with your report from Greenland. It was incredible to see how fast the water was moving and the rapid melting of the ice. Those moulins are awfully deep and you were brave to crawl to the rim of one of those caves. Steffen is doing some very important work to show what is happening with the climate change. Hopefully the seas won't rise too much to cause loss of land. I applaud you for your camping efforts and cooking skills. I think both the Cheeseheads and the Pastaheads did great! Although I do favor the Pastaheads a little more. Great job Anne and crew! And now you can try to cook at home Anne!    
The sensationalism of this report destroys it's merit and is an insult to the single researcher interviewed. Surely, Konrad Steffen is a respected researcher in his field, yet there are many researchers in the field of Climatology that have established and publicly debated projections of global climate change.  None would ever be as bold to connect the measurements of one moulin, glacial calving and sea level rise in Bangladesh as Anne Thompson does in her report. Take for example the study by Martin Wild, Pierluigi Calanca, Simon C. Scherrer and Atsumu Ohmura of the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich in the Journal of Geophysical Research as reported in the Sept./Oct 2003 issue of American Scientist Sept/Oct. One possible model they investigated showed that Greenland's net contribution to sea level "rise" was a 4-29% decrease in the thermal expansion of the oceans projected to occur if global CO2 levels double in the next 70 years. In other words, sea level "rise" might actually be a fall when considering the basics of the water cycle: warmer oceans, increased precipitation, increased accumulation of ice in the polar regions.

Again this is an alternate model to the one Anne Thompson posits, and their are many more. This issue is complex and needs to be conveyed not as a cause and effect elementary school science project: "If Greenland ice caps melt, then Bangladesh is drowned in sea water." Please give researchers more credit and give science it's due as a forum for investigating multiple hypotheses to describe natural phenomena and not as a mystical medium for predicting the future.
Let's hear some stories about the growing Antarctic ice sheet. Or, doesnt't that fit the "global warming" template? So much for ojectivity.
Mark, Global warming models actually predicted a growing of the arctic ice sheet.  If you raise the temperatures form -50 to - 45 you still have freezing snow...  don't you?  What is now surprising scientists is the fact that the western Antarctic ice sheet is disappearing at an alarming rate and other areas are not growing nearly as fast as they thought they might given the higher moisture content in the air.  Since living efficiently and more self-sufficiently is good to do for many "OTHER" important reasons, I don't see why there is such an outright attempt to discredit such experienced scientists.  Even if you discount global warming, this is obviously a much more dangerous planet than most people would care to admit.  Fortunately, measures made to live more efficiently and sustainably like with solar energy, also lead to much greater levels of disaster preparedness as there would never be a storm/accident/earthquake/terror attack that could crash the entire power grid or cause an energy/gas shortage.  Your choice!  I choose not to place my world or its children at such an irresponsible risk.
Hello, My name is Pam and Im a student at Burlington County Institute of Technology. My career major is GeoScience. We study things from GIS(Geographical Information systems), weather, space, and we are also involved in a program called GLOBE. I was intrested in this topic and I saw it lastnight and I belive that this is in the hands of my generaiton. Everyday I am reminded that this is real and we have to stop it.
After watching and hearing about all the ice/glaciers melting and causing more water flow towards the state, I thought that the people that live in those areas should be notified. I hope that doesn't ever happen, but if there is a chance I sure hope everyone knows world wide. Please let people know whats going on around the world. Thanks.
I was unclear as to wether this is a series on Greenland. If it is, will one of the segments focus on the 8-900 CE (Current Era) era farms that are being uncovered as the ice melts near the coast.
Anne,
I was moved by your segment and photos depicting how fast the ice is melting.  It was startling to hear an esteemed researcher declare that an immediate effect could increase sea levels 20 feet.  I thought of all those places, in addition to Florida and The Netherlands, that will be impacted.  Here in Laguna Beach, CA our downtown would be underwater.
However, I was also struck by your bravery as you went out to the edge of that deep hole.  I'm glad you wore a harness, but still....
Though I agree with the first post of Chris Eldridge, I thank you for doing the piece.
Jinger


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

RECENT STORIES FROM NIGHTLY NEWS

  • Nightly News section front

CONNECT WITH US

About the broadcast | Biographies

RSS is an easy way to get the news you want as it is updated even if you are not on MSNBC.com. More information about MSNBC.com's RSS feeds.

Subscribe to feed

Podcasting brings you audio and video from each weekday broadcast on your iPod or other portable MP3 player anytime, anywhere. More information about MSNBC.com's podcasts.

Subscribe to podcast

Sign-up for our daily e-mail newsletter. It offers a preview of the stories and special reports featured on each weekday broadcast.


Syndicate This Site

Add The Daily Nightly to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google