ABOUT THIS BLOG

The Daily Nightly began on May 31, 2005. As Brian wrote in his first post it aims to provide a narrative of the broadcast day and a window into the editorial process at NBC Nightly News. Brian weighs in every weekday and NBC News correspondents and producers post regularly.

Brian Williams became the seventh anchor and managing editor in the history of NBC Nightly News on December 2, 2004. Read his full biography.



PURPLE HEARTED CANDOR

Posted: Friday, July 27, 2007 3:32 PM by Rob Merrill
Filed Under:

By John Rutherford, NBC News Washington


VIDEO: In this raw video shot by NBC News at Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Spc. Jason Pinney, 24, of Decatur, Ind., receives a Purple Heart for a wound he suffered in Afghanistan.

Do Americans appreciate the sacrifices being made by U.S. troops in Iraq and Afghanistan? I suspect most people would say, "Yes, of course I do," but some soldiers disagree.

"I think some of you would probably agree that there's some people out in our country that may not realize that we are at war, and you see it sometimes every day," Brig. Gen. Michael Tucker said at a ceremony today for 14 soldiers receiving Purple Hearts at Walter Reed Army Medical Center.

"The military is at war, but the country is not," University of Maryland sociologist David Segal told the Washington Post Magazine. "And the military resents that."

Does it? Not according to the soldiers receiving Purple Hearts today.

"This is our job," said Spc. Joshua Lutz, 24, of Palm Harbor, Fla., who was wounded by a roadside bomb in Iraq. "It's like people who go to work every day in office buildings. That's their job. This is what we do."

Sgt. Luis Rivera-Valentin, 30, of Toa Baja, Puerto Rico, wounded in a Baghdad bomb explosion, agreed.

"Our job is to do whatever we have to do," Rivera-Valentin said. "That's what we're here for."

The soldiers were more ambivalent about whether they're appreciated by the American people.

"Americans, a good portion of them, they care more that Paris Hilton got out of jail, they care more that something's on sale than their own out there fighting for them," said SSgt. Scott Gentry, 31, of Spokane, Wash., wounded in the face by a roadside bomb.

Sgt. Luis Martinez-Ramirez, 38, of Vega Alta, Puerto Rico, injured in the same blast as Sgt. Rivera-Valentin, believes the public owes the troops a debt of gratitude.

"They should appreciate the sacrifice we are doing every single day," he said, "because we are trying to keep terrorism away from home."

Pfc. Ian Gillis, 20, of Santa Rosa, Calif., believes their sacrifices are appreciated.

"For the most part, I think America's behind the common soldier, whether they believe in the politics of it or not," he said.

What do you think? We'd like to hear from you. Please "Discuss" below to share your opinion.

Washington Producer John Rutherford is a decorated Vietnam veteran. He posts a weekly blog on burials of service members at Arlington National Cemetery.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I am a 20 year Marine's mom.  In a very real way, I'm a 20 year vet too.  I have watched the very best that my country had to offer (men and women)do what they do.  I have feared for my son's safety and watched as he continued to make the choices which put him and his men "in harms way".  It was what he did and it is "what they do". The politics don't matter to these men and women.  They are the best.  They are all my kids.  No matter what the uniform.  I am proud to say that my country produced them.  The best of the best. And on top of it, they are  motivated to help one another (the squad is all they have at any given moment) and to help the civilians caught in the middle of a terriable mess.  It doesn't get better than that.

Mary Houston, Tx (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:39 PM)

As a former USMC officer, whose son-in-las is active duty USAF, I believe the average American's support doesn't go beyond a metallic "support our troops" ribbon on their car.  I question whether or not Americans deserve the military they have.  Civilians are making no sacrifices because the politicians are afraid to upset their constituency.

Dennis Kearns, East Hanover, N.J. (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:44 PM)

Our President does not repsect the soldiers. Beause he did not prepare a strategy for the war in Iraq, soldiers have died. He sent too few soldiers to do the job of securing the country. He also did not equip the soldiers properly.

Larry, Montgomery, AL (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:44 PM)

Being a Vet and a proud Dad of a Soldier, I know there's a lot of truth there.  Most of the people I talk to have to be reminded that there are good people out there covering their back.  But the common Soldier also appreciates that the country can go about it's business without worrying about it.  The wolves are at the door, but the Sheepdogs are on duty.  Sleep well America!!

kball (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:46 PM)

I think they are right on the money.  I honestly believe that more Americans were concerned about Paris Hilton (or any number of things in their personal lives) than the fact that people are fighting and dieing for them.  I don't know what the percentage is, but I believe it is a majority.  I also believe that many Soldiers do resent this....and they have every right to.

D. R. Dale, Russellville, Arkansas (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:46 PM)

I was wounded in Ramadi on May 19, 2006. I came home to a very appreciative community. Of course as the days and weeks go on, the attention begins to fade. I agree that a lot of people care more about Paris Hilton than they do about the war. But that is OK. We are an all volunteer force. I always took pride in the fact that I serve so others do not have to. I am glad that my friends and family can go on with their lives. I am also glad that they have not seen what I have seen.

John, Philadelphia, PA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:46 PM)

In Connecticut, at the State-run Rocky Hill Veterans Home & Hospital, there are myriad of ordinary citizens volunteering to make life better for our Vets at the hospital:  American Legions run Bingo, musicians volunteer to play "Thank You" Concerts, Eagle Scouts earn their Eagle promotions by good works.  There are dozens of "Friends of the Vets" who visit and attend services.  Yes, there are plenty of people who hate the war but love our Veterans.  I am the daughter, sister, aunt, cousin and granddaughter of people who served (and continue to serve) in the military, and whenever I go to the Hospital, it's like I'm visiting my own family.  I hope that wherever my family service-members are, other volunteers will do the same for them too.  I don't support this war - but I love our veterans. I don't sport a bumper sticker - I keep you in my heart.  Come home safe - we love you all.

Cece, Newington, CT (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:47 PM)

American's MUST NOT forget that we are at war!  When our military is at war, we as a nation are at war as well.  Our soldiers are risking their lives everyday; we MUST recognize and respect that.

Ginny, Dahinda, Illinois (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:49 PM)

I appreciate the American soldier every day. I was in the army and station overseas. I am very lucky that I didnot see combat - but I still understand the scrafice and commitment these guys make. I do not think the government does enough to take care of them when they come home or are wounded that portion of it a shame and criminal. They should have retraining and some way to re-enter in the work force and get the medical care they deserve - we ddo not pay them very well so they should recieve a good compensation package when they are done with the commitment they made to this country- God Bless and Keep our Soldiers

Mike Cicak Northport Florida (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:49 PM)

The war is a farce. i am not saying that our soldiers are not sacrificing , but unfortunately the majority of them are under oath to do what they are told. That is the military. George W Bush has no real respect for our troops. his war is fought for profit...his and his cronies. They LIED...they continue to LIE.
This is not a war gaainst terrorism. It is a war of Big busines, and those profiting dont care if you boys live or die. That is the sad truth. I do support the troops...I support them by protesting to bring them home and every one should be doing the same thing.

Drew C Smith, Vineland, NJ. (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:52 PM)

I am one that appreciates and worries about our men and women at war.  I believe that if not for their sacrifices and those of countless others, we could not continue to enjoy our freedoms.  I for one, am one that believes that we as a country could show our warriors more appreciation by way of budget increases for higher pay, better weapons and uniforms and higher grade equipment AND I feel that we as a country should be outraged at the punishment of these brave warriors for doing  what we sent them to do.  I know that I am very blessed to be in a country where I have a voice to say this and I thank all our military branches for keeping us free...  Please count me as one of the few who love our military and also feel that they are NOT truly appreciated.

Sandra Metoyer, Oceanside, Ca (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:54 PM)

I know how those soldiers feel because I am a "part-time soldier." I am serving in the Guard and was deployed to Iraq in 2004. While I was there; my whole world was evolving around my job; and my only connectin with reality was that of my family. I was also very appreciative to have received many necessary packages from supporting Americans & patriots (and yes, cookies from the Girl Scouts and patriotic singers, etc).
However; when I came home after the deployment; I saw that Americans seemed to have been carrying on with their lives as though there was not a war. I also tried my hardest to get back to normalcy and soon carrying on without missing a beat. I was deployed once again since, and the second time was a little better in term of keeping things in perspective. I had a job to do and I did what I was sworn on to do. It took me much less time to re-adjust after my second deployment.
Perhaps I have a better insight than some, thus not suffering from bitternes or PTSD. However, it's good to have the American public to continue to function as if there is not a war going on. After all, aren't we supposed to keep our economy going and keep America strong? Don't we need to let the bad guys know that they can't dampen our American spirit with their potshots?

David, Plano, Texas (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:57 PM)

I'm an Army vet and I agree that most Americans only pay lip service to "support our troops"

Mark Bersanti PGH, PA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:58 PM)

Every morning and every evening I say a prayer for all our soldiers, at home or afar.  I also include all their families and love ones.  These are the quite one's who protecting  America, doing whatever is needed even losing their lives. Please be assured that you are thought of and prayed for my millions.  The majority are always quite but each one of us deeply appreciate your time, your youth and your separation from family, that you sacrifice for our country and for each and every American. We know this is very hard but you still are there guarding America for all of us.  Thank You is not enough but that's all I can give you besides my prayers,   Thank you again and many God Bless you and bring you safety home.

Melody Carson (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 4:59 PM)

America deserves the great Military that we have. Our military deserves a far better civilian leadership than the liars and crooks in Washington today.

Nick Clear, Alameda, CA. (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:01 PM)

I, for one, fully support our troops.  They are doing their jobs heroically and bravely.  Without them, our shores would have been invaded generations ago.  They protect me and my children and I have the highest respect for them and their sacrifices and the sacrifices of their families.  

I also am fully against this war.  The soldiers, marines and navy personnel are not the ones who started this war, they are simply the tools that the administration is using to propogate this grand stupidity.  Whatever my personal feelings on this war, our troops are not the ones to be disrespected.  I salute all of them and bless them everyday.

My first instinct was that Iraq was the wrong place and the wrong time.  Our invasion of Afganistan was different.  We were after the people who actually did have something to do with 9/11. Am I glad Saddam is gone?  Of course, he needed to go.  But the wisdom of the how and when seems to have escaped this administration.  There were other ways to ensure his end without the carnage that has ensued.

But in the meantime, I want our troops to know that I separate administrative policy (Rep or Dem) from the actions and efforts of our troops.  Always have known the difference, always will.  When you do your job, you earn more respect than we could ever repay.

Proud of our troops, Grand Rapids, MI (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:01 PM)

I have nothing but respect for the young men and women risking and sometimes losing thier lives every day in the middle east. If the politicians in Washington had the same sense of duty and courage as the soldiers fighting for us over there, we would have brought our troops home from a stable middle east in victory a long time ago.

John Hansen, seattle washington USA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:04 PM)

I am very proud of our soldiers.   I work at a VA hospital and try my best to make sure that every soldier(not matter their age) I help to the best of my power.  I am also a mother of an air force soldier that have served in Iraq twice and most of all, as a mother I am veeeeerrrrrryyyyyyyy proud of my son and all the sons of this great nation.  GOD BLESS THEM ALL.  

NANCY HEWITT, TX (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:05 PM)

I served 39 months active duty as a U.S. Army officer in the 1970's. I did not see combat, but I served with many who did fight in Vietnam. I have nothing but the highest respect for our men and women serving in harm's way. If we are truly "at war," this country needs to be on a war footing. We should reinstate the draft, greatly increase the size of the regular forces and appropriate billions more for defense. A country is either "at war" or it's not. As long as the President and Congress do not like the U.S. is not truly "at war," most Americans are going to follow their lead. That regrettable, but it's reality.

Jim, The Mississippi Delta (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:06 PM)

If the Administration didn't go to great lengths to hide the caskets returning from Iraq/Afghanistan, and to hide the wounded from the view of the American citizens, the American citizens would be much more aware of the fact that this is a real war and our soldiers are risking life and limb. How many photos do you see of Paris in Hilton in the course of a week? And how many images of wounded soldiers do you see in a week? How many flag draped caskets?

Gregory, Baltimore, MD (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:09 PM)

El Paso, Texas
As the wife of a retired Army CWO, I say if the Army was sent to do a job, the politicians should leave them alone and let them do their job. They have been training years five them what they need to fight and stop worrying about how the world critizises the USA, the USA is the police of the world, as americans we were asked to do this police job, let us do it and stop bickering at home, politics have no room in war.

Mrs V Marchael El Paso, Texas (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:13 PM)

Our troops are magnificent, the best of the best.Their courage and commitment are unquestionable. Unfortunatly their commander in chief is not up to their level. The war in Iraq is not about defending us from terrorists or spreading democracy it is about protecting our interest in the oil fields there and in adjacent countries.  

John Neuteboom (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:20 PM)

USMC RETIRED. AS LONG AS WE HAVE YOUNG MEN AND WOMEN WILLING TO DO THE HARDEST THINGS A COUNTRY CAN ASK A PERSON TO DO WE WILL BE A GREAT COUNTRY.
IT IS IMPORTANT FOR NON MILITARY PEOPLE TO APPRECIATE THE SACRIFICES MADE EVERYDAY BY OUR MEN AND WOMEN IN UNIFORM.
IT SHOULD NOT BE THE FOCUS OF THE MILITARY AS TO WETHER THEY DO OR NOT.  THAT IS PART OF THE SACRIFICE. MY COUNTRY RIGHT OR WRONG IS MY COUNTRY.  IN THIS COUNTRY IT IS A CHOICE TO SERVE.  

CARL LAKE FOREST CALIFORNIA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:21 PM)

The only real time, as I see it, that the American people truly were at war alongside our troops was WWII. We were at total war with the Axis countries. We felt the strain because we made sacrifices of rations, time in factories, and on the front lines. We as a society were fighitng with our military. We appreciated them when they got home, as we still appreciate them with memorials and Steven Spielberg movies. There's a reason they're called "the greatest generation."
Unfortunately, that's not the case with our military and government now. THen, there was an openness that Pres. Roosevelt had with the American people. Now, we need a FOIA paper and an act of Congress to get the truth.
Why the drop-off? Why the change?

David, Denver (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:23 PM)

As a combat aircrewman wounded in Iraq, I take issue with the 'support the troops but not the war' movement.  Do those of you who protest realize that you voted not once, but twice to send me and mine into harm's way?  In 2002, your elected representatives passed the War Powers Act, allowing the President to use military force against Iraq.  Two years later, in 2004, you, the American people, again voted to send us to war by re-electing President Bush.  

Why is it now, when US body counts are dropping and 85% of Iraq is under control, (some of it to the degree that parents allow their children to walk to school) that you voice your loud complaints?

We are doing what you as the American public ASKED us to do.  This nation voted to send us to war on two seperate occasions.  How is it that you now have the audacity to demand anything from any member of the military, from the lowliest of E-1s to the Commander-in-Chief?

AT2 (AW/NAC) Stephen Johnson (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:23 PM)

I agree with everything Mary Houston, Tx stated earlier. I too am a mother of a young soldier. We will never be able to do enough to repay these brave young men & women in our military today. Everyday they are sacificing so much that the majority of Americans would never sacifice. They may feel that it's their job and that is what they do but we as a country need to appreciate every one of them. They are all our kids. Their medical and financial needs should be taken care of by the our government who is responsible for them when they are sent to war for this country.

Carol Taylor, Phoenix, AZ (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:29 PM)

I am appalled at the fact that a few are sacrificing so much and most are sacrificing nothing, in some cases even profiting from the war. It is an outrage that some of the richest citizens are given a tax break while others give their lives and limbs. I pray for out rroops and their loved ones.

Marion Erwin (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:36 PM)

Welcome to the real world.  When I was in Nahm no one cared.  At least these guys are getting more thanks than I did.

Jim Dallas, Texas (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:37 PM)

Why should I, an average American, care about the soldiers? The war in Iraq is led by a President who has overwhelming support from the military. The soldiers support this war that has made the world a more dangerous place and dramaticaly increased the support for terrorism against the US. What the volunteer soldiers are doing is making things worse for me as an average American.
Why should I care about the wars in Iraq and Aphganistan? I'm not paying for them; we are borrowing the billions of dollars to pay for these wars; my kids will pay for it with interest. I'm not sacrificing for it; there's no draft so none of my kids will fight in it unless they are dumb enough to enlist.
If you are a soldier, quit your whinning. If you don't like the risks of fighting for a President and Vice President who avoided service during their generation's war, Vietnam, get angry. Whatever you do, as an average American, I'm tired of reading about surveys showing soldiers' support for our incompetent President and then having to listen to them whine about the consequences. As soldiers fighting in Iraq and Aphganistan you are not making the world a safer place. in fact you are making it far more likely that me, as an average American, will be the target of terrorism. Please stop. And if you don't stop supporting the President and his wars, stop saying you are doing it for me.  

Gearge Q. Citisen (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:39 PM)

The men and women who make up our armed forces in this country are under appreciated no matter how much we try to show our appreciation.  The sacrifices they make, so that the rest of us do not have to, are deserving of a level of gratitude that is impossible to express.  I hope that the civillian population will continue to support them until the task is complete in the middle east and they can leave the area stable so that the sacrifices that have been made are not in vain.  I also hope that the politicians will stop using the war and the soldiers as political tools as they prepare for the next election.

Dennis Wells Roanoke Rapids NC (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:40 PM)

I concur. I spent a year in Iraq and you really to simply accept it as part of the job. When you enlist you know it's a possibility. If you're deployed, you do your job. It's just what you do. If you can't deal with that, things become very difficult for everyone.

Joe, Lompoc, CA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:40 PM)

It is heartbredaking to see the lives and idealism of responsible, heroic - albeit naive - young people squandered by a cynical and greedy administration. Saddam Hussein was an evil dictator, but he posed no threat to us. And as bad as he was, if Iraqis could turn back the clock and have him back, they'd jump at the chance.
So why are we there? Follow the money! The soldiers were deliberately deceived: a poll showed that over 70% thought Saddam had a connection with 9/11, even after Cheney was forced to admit that none existed.  Al Qaida was unwelcome in Iraq, until our military broke the doors down.

So, yeah, I support the troops - they're our sons and brothers. But I can't support what they're doing. It's wrong.

Kumquatmae, Santa Rosa, CA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:42 PM)

The basic truth is and always has been that war is instigated by men in suits far from the blood and mayhem of combat. Those "suits" do not support the troops, in spite of their huge flags, their flag pins and their pious look as they say the Pledge of Allegiance. Of course, I support the men and women on the ground but they are being ordered to put their lives on the line, every minute, by "suits". What I don't support is invading a sovereign country by selling American citizens a mythical reason for losing almost 4,000 lives and inflicting horrendous injuries on thousands and thousands. And as for Mrs. Marchael, El Paso, "let the soldiers do their job" statement is just ridiculous. What job are they to do in the mayhem and civil war of Iraq when even the leader of this once-proud country can't articulate what the job is? My sympathy and respect for both the soldiers and their families in this nightmare is boundless. My respect for the White House is zilch, zero, nada.

Violet Cauthon, Las Cruces, NM (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:43 PM)

My son is on his 4th tour in Afganistan. He has more issues with his high command and the civilian administrators of the military. As a 30 year retired Naval Officer from SpecWar I can't disagree with him.

I just hope he does not end up with a Taliban Marksman Medal aka The Purple Heart.

Satcong, San Francisco, CA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:46 PM)

I don't think the nation is behind our soldiers, or any of our other "first responders." From the highest government officials on down, we are not making the welfare of these people our first priority, even though they have made our welfare their first priority. Every day I read of war veterans and emergency personnel who responded to the Sept. 11th attacks trying to get recognition for their injuries and needs, and plowing through reams of red tape to get the help that they should be getting automatically. Some even have had to take legal action. I feel that they have been treated as objects to be used and then discarded when they can no longer serve the cause, rather than as our nation's honored finest, and the blame starts at the top.The fact that they are volunteers means that they stepped forward as patriots to help their community in a time of crisis while others did not do so;it does not mean that they are hired mercenaries to be dismissed with a small payoff.

Patricia A. Scanlin, Laurel, Md. (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:52 PM)

America cares very much about it's troops. Through the ballot-box America has made it clear that the war was ill-advised, our troops are being squandered, and they should be brought home.  In the aftermath of 9/11 the country was angry and ready to strike wherever the President said we should. Had we pointed our guns in the right direction, the country would be standing behind the President; no matter how difficult the job. But now we know that we were sold a bill of goods. I don't know what President Bush's motives were (vengeance for his Dad?) but he's wasting American lives and it needs to stop.  I'm a Vietnam Vet (volunteer) and I know why I was there. Our methods may have been flawed, and the interference of our politicians disgraceful, but we were trying to do something meaningful. Our troops in Iraq were sent under false pretenses, and it's only their own professionalism & honor that they have to keep them going.  It's time they came home.

Western Yankee (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:54 PM)

Our troops in Afganistan and Iraq aren't garnering the full gamut of "support" from the general populace, because there is no belief in this country that the troops are "fighting for us" or "protecting us" or anything else of that nature.  They are doing their sworn duty to obey orders, and as such, command and deserve our admiration for sticking to the game plan.  The greedy nature of our involvement in Iraq precludes me from doing more than feel sympathy/empathy for the troops overseas.  I know that if this country was, in fact, defending itself, then there would be no end to the outpouring of intense, deep emotional support for all our armed forces, and the country at large.  It is sad to see the present assault on our constitution, and worrisome that one day, these same servicemembers may be forced to decide if an order to fire on fellow Americans is a lawful order or not.  If we continue down the current path, that decision is not that far off.  How would you REALLY react to martial law being declared in the United States?  I am a liberal, but because of the potential of our government turning on us, I will never give up the battle to maintain the RIGHT to bear arms.  Some will say this is very alarmist, and pessimistic, some will agree.  I think we can all agree that our country needs to stick to ALL of the guiding principles established in the US Constitution, the primary one being that "all men are created equal".

Steve Sallis, San Diego, CA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:56 PM)

The question of whether you support the troops is both simple and complex.  Yes, I, and I suspect the overwhelming majority of Americans, support the troops in the sense that we desire their safety abroad, and most importantly, their safe return.  Moreover, I, and I suspect the same majority, support whichever immediate action they are involved in - insofar as it means their safety prevailing over their opponents (translate: if someone must be hurt, I'd/we'd prefer it be their enemy to them).  

But the question of whether we support the overall mission that our Congress authorized our Chief Executive to send the troops is quite different.  Indeed, at this point in time, all indications are that our country no longer supports their presence in Iraq.  

My point is this: that as an American, you can  desire the troops be successful in battle, while simultaneously believing that the decision (made by others than those fighting) to enter battle was improper.  

In short, a citizen can support the troops and advocate for ending the war.  The concepts are not mutually exclusive.  Unfortunately for proponents of rational thinking, there are thos that insist otherwise.

Anthony, Chicago, Illinois (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:58 PM)

I personally want to thank every SERVICE PERSON in the military for there commitment and bravery that they have demonstrated now and in the past wars and police actions. I truly believe that we have  the finest forces in the entire world. So please do not look for a ribbon, Look at the person wearing the uniform and simply walk up to them, Shake there hand and simply say THANK YOU! That is what everyone in the military today want. Just to be appreciated and remembered.

John Comer (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:59 PM)

USN 1958 1965 Vietnam era 1963 1965 I support the Worrier not the war god bless them,

james r lang (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 5:59 PM)

Unfortunately, the military is taking a huge bashing these days - from the media,from the congress and even from the inexperienced civilian leaders at the DOD.  Bashing our military leaders is demoralizing not supportive.  These men and woman were not appointed to their positions, they earned them and in some cases through YEARS of sacrifice and hard work.  No one loves the war - but bashing the people who have been ordered into it is not supportive on any level.  

Army Family Member, VA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:11 PM)

I don't blame the soldiers for feeling that they and their families are the only ones making sacrifices. I hope these expressions get greater play out there, as Americans need to wake up to how wrong it is. I too am bothered that we civilians on a whole are blithely going about our business in We should enjoy life of course, and not put all joy on hold, but a little more acknowledgment of THEIR daily sacrifices should be woven into our day, however small form that takes. Instead, we have our no-holds-barred Oscar, Emmy, Grammy ceremonies, and so on with nothing spared. A "hello- we're all thinking of you" to the troops should be included in these broadcasts at minimum. I saw footage the other day of the wild celebrations in the street after WWII- the military got the kind of heroes' welcome that we should be preparing for our troops. Instead, very little fanfare for them, but lots for the goof-off celebrities of the same age. That I'm against the war is beside the point, but unfortunately our true heroes are being short-changed because of our country's failure to make the distinction between our heroes serving us, and a war that most of us disagree with. They're all heroes regardless.

Sonya Johnson, Glendale, CA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:15 PM)

One remark stated that "Civilians are making no sacrifices because the politicians are afraid to upset their constituency."  While we may not be making personal sacrifices, our esprit de corps has taken a drastic hit over the years.  We were lied to about this war, and we were duped into believing that we had to fight it for one reason--terrorism abatement, and then were later told that it was actually to get rid of the terrorist Saddam Hussein, and now we're being told that we have to continue the fight because the government of Iraq cannot maintain its own security.  When our vice president said, several years ago, that "[we] are in the last throes of the insurgency," and years later the insurgency is worse than ever, that makes me question the validity of your statement, "Civilians are making no sacrifices because the politicians are afraid to upset their constituency."  The politicians are lying.  They are lying to the American people, and they are lying to the rest of the world.  Civilians may not be making any sacrifices yet, but when all of this massive debt catches up to us, we and our children and their children are going to be sacrificing a lot.

Mike Gambino, Portland, OR (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:16 PM)

I for one, have supported our troops from the very beginning of this useless war, and will continue to support them. When I am at the airport I shake the hand of every soldier I see and thank them for serving their country. Most of us do not care what happens to Paris Hilton, that is the media just needing something to fill air time as there is not enough real news to fill the 24-7 format. Don't lose faith in us our valiant warriors, because we will not lose faith in you. We sent a message to our politicians in the last election and we will continue to do so. God bless you all................

Michael Hillhouse, Cumming, Georgia (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:16 PM)

I am a veteran of the USNavy, WW@, and did a hitch in the USArmy between WW2 and the Korean War.  Of course I appreciate our troops, and support them to the extent that I can.  However, I expect that most people in any nation or analogous group appreciate and support their troops, no matter which side they are on.  For example, it appears that many in the Islamic world appreciate and support the 'troops' who fight ours in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Gordon Fisher, South Salem, NY (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:25 PM)

Because it's been so long that our troops have been gone, it's become routine for us to see them come and go.  That is the environment out president has created for us.  I hold every single one of our soldiers in my heart everyday.  What angers me the most is that our troops are proud to serve their country and the president that gives them the orders, however, our president does NOT honor what his voters have asked him, he has not been up front about the truth, and he continues to be the stubborn man that he made a mistake.  Every single family that has lost a son or daughter needs a deep gratitude and apology from the president.  Every single soldier who continues to fight deserves the utmost respect, gratitude, honor, and appreciation from everyone here at home.  This war has changed the lives of every single soldier and their families, and will forever change the lives of their children.  How do we, as Americans reconcile that Mr. President?  How do we deal with the loss and your lies?  I guess you will never have an answer until you have felt it on your own skin.  But then non of your family memebers are there fighting for us are they?  

Jim, Studio City, CA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:27 PM)

As an American who spends half his life overseas in different countries I feel torn with emotion watching this war (as alot of Americans are)and seeing the image of America and its military, abroad. Sure the Army's job is to fight when they are ordered - I know I've always slept better knowing they are there- but should they be sacrificed as they are in Iraq? I am angry with people who think if you are not in favor of the war you don't support our troops. I'm angry with most of the American public who care more about Paris Hilton than why, how and who is responsible for our country's military being in Iraq and what's happening to soldiers physically and mentally. I'm angry that I have to watch foreign newscasts (esp CBC Canada) to see the true horror of what our troops are needlessly going through. I'm angry that we haven't taken to the streets in protest like the Vietnam era to demand a withdrawal of our troops. I'm angry when I see our troops on TV scaring (or worse) innocent civilians when I know these soldiers are really good people if they just weren't in this illegal war. I'm angry that the administration has not been held accountable for leading the battle off Aghanistan and Bin Laden and into a country that they knew was not a threat. I wish our troops could go home to their families, alive and with all their limbs. I wish that a way out could be secured because the idea that continuing this war somehow makes us safer is insane. All this war is doing is assisting terrorism to grow in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and other Muslim countries and alienating our Allies. Our leaders have learned nothing from history. Support our troops by bringing them home alive!

Eugene Mc Guinness, Bellingham WA (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:31 PM)

yup, if the bar-b-que does not light up nothing else matters ... obviously, we are losing our fiber like our leaders who use all our young kids for political gerrymandering ...

me, somewhere, US (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:32 PM)

I SERVED 11 1/2 YEARS IN THE MARINE CORPS,HALF OF THAT WITH "THE FIGHTING-FIFTH MARINES"(WEAPONS-CO),AND WE ALL AS AMERICANS NEED TO SUPPORT OUR TROOPS NO MATTER WHAT GOES ON IN WASHINGTON. "OUR MEN"(NOT-BOYS),ARE IN COMBAT, AND THEY NEED US BEHIND THEM ALL THE WAY....WE AS A NATION MUST STOP THE MAJOR "FUNGUS" THAT IS AMOUNGST, (TERRIORISM)....WE HAVE TO STOP THEM IN THEIR OWN BACK YARDS, NOT OURS...LET'S DESTROY THIS DISEASE THAT IS TRYING TO DESTROY OUR COUNTRY AND BRING OUR TROOPS HOME TO PROTECT US HERE....SEMPER'FI

BOOIE GOULD 10117 AVE "M" CHICAGO, ILL 60617 (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:41 PM)

I represent those who oppose the war but suppose the troops – and do so with time and money.  I oppose the President and his foolish bumper sticker slogans that pass for supporting the troops.  I want to scream, then vomit when I see a gas-guzzling car or truck going down the street with one of those magnets that read "Support our Troops" (you know who you are).  But I DO put my efforts and my money where my beliefs lie.  I buy phone cards for our soldiers and send care packages several times a year (last Christmas spending >$500).  I sold my gas-guzzler and bought a Prius.  It's not as much as I’d like to do - but a lot more than Bush has ever asked us to do (oh, I forgot – go shopping so the terrorists don’t win).  

Randy, Moody, ME (Sent Friday, July 27, 2007 6:53 PM)



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

 Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

NBC NEWS IN THE BLOGOSPHERE

More Daily Nightly

Recent Posts:

Archives:

Categories:

RECENT STORIES FROM NIGHTLY NEWS

  • Nightly News section front

CONNECT WITH US

About the broadcast | Biographies

RSS is an easy way to get the news you want as it is updated even if you are not on MSNBC.com. More information about MSNBC.com's RSS feeds.

Subscribe to feed

Podcasting brings you audio and video from each weekday broadcast on your iPod or other portable MP3 player anytime, anywhere. More information about MSNBC.com's podcasts.

Subscribe to podcast

Sign-up for our daily e-mail newsletter. It offers a preview of the stories and special reports featured on each weekday broadcast.


Syndicate This Site

Add The Daily Nightly to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google

MSNBC Weblogs